Saint Louis Beacon

Thursday
Nov 20th
           | 
 
Home arrow Voices arrow In the News arrow How will media changes affect the election?
How will media changes affect the election? Print E-mail
By Lana Stein, Special to the Beacon   
Last Updated ( Thursday, 21 August 2008 )
 

Despite numerous changes to communications over the past half century, the focus of presidential campaign coverage in the U.S. remains the same. It's the horserace: Who is ahead? Who may catch up? But other aspects have changed. More information and information of different types are available to the voter. Yet, whether voters are really better informed is open to question.

Timothy Crouse covered the reporters covering the presidential candidates in 1972. In his book, The Boys on the Bus, he described the phenomenon of "pack journalism." Editors did not want anything original in coverage and the three TV networks did not want a story that had not appeared in The New York Times. Reporters reported what was said at campaign stops but did not question the veracity of the remarks. Female reporters such as Helen Thomas and Cassie Mackin, not part of the boys, did challenge presidential statements but they were the exception.

Today, that pack mentality has been tempered significantly by a new trinity of information sources. Talk radio, cable news and the internet provide a cacophony of information that interacts with traditional print media and network nightly newscasts. In some cases, reporters have become performers, and reporting and commentary are hopelessly comingled.

Rush Limbaugh may be the leader in making talk radio a constant for many. For three hours every weekday, Limbaugh gives his conservative views of the body politic. He has numerous imitators, most of whom also adhere to a conservative vision. Rush is far removed from the old pack.

Since its inception almost three decades ago, cable news has grown and its reach has become more extensive. CNN was the pioneer, with an initial style based on traditional journalism. Now, however, CNN, Fox News and MSNBC offer news filtered by opinion. Candidate surrogates, commentators and reporters from print frequently appear on the news shows. Straight news often merges with opinion.

The media outlets all have web sites, which parlay breaking news and commentary. And the Internet can be the origin of news stories. Rev. Jeremiah Wright's sermons were put on YouTube and repeated everywhere. A contributor to the Huffington Post, a web-based news site, broke the story of Barack Obama's "bitter" comments. The web is also filled with bloggers who develop issues and keep them in the public eye. Again, fact and opinion are frequently merged.

This newer trinity of information sources spins stories from one to the other with great rapidity. A minor gaffe can become major with constant repetition. Traditional media also report these stories but seem to have less of the constant spin.

Are voters better informed? Most American households have cable or satellite TV and an increasing number have home computers. The constancy of news coverage and its incessant commentary affect traditional coverage and reach voters in some form. Traditional reporters have become analysts; for example, many on MSNBC are highlighted as analysts for that network as well as writers or editors for newspapers or magazines.

Nonetheless, the horserace aspect still predominates. How many stories were about when Sen. Clinton would drop out of the race for the nomination or who would be a vice presidential candidate and how would that add to the Electoral College map?

The ubiquity of poll results adds to the now exaggerated feeding frenzy. There's a daily tracking poll and results from other polls pop up frequently. They are also interpreted within the framework of bias of the new trinity. It's not unusual for those on cable and elsewhere to set an expectation bar and evaluate candidate performance based on the criteria they themselves have set.

The story is still the same -- who is winning -- but it is now propagated much more widely. The old pack and its straight reporting have been superseded by a horde of opinion makers with their own ideological trappings. An important topic for study would be to see how talk radio, cable news, and Internet sources affect voter perceptions of candidates and issues. Have the changes in the game changed the outcome?

Lana Stein, St. Louis, is professor emerita of political science, University of Missouri at St. Louis. To reach her, contact Beacon features and commentary editor Donna Korando.

 

   

Users' Comments  RSS feed comment
 

Average user rating

 


Add your comment
Only registered users can comment on an article. Please login or register.

No comment posted



mXcomment 1.0.6 © 2007-2008 - visualclinic.fr
License Creative Commons - Some rights reserved
No Comments.
Discuss this item on the forums. (0 posts)

Editors' Picks

  • National
    • Bill Ayers apologizes? Well, not really. And what he should be saying right now is thank you to Barack Obama for putting him back in the limelight. | Clarence Page, Chicago Tribune

    • Has Obama really quit smoking? Maybe not: So he's not a superman. Neither are we. In a democracy, that is a good thing for ruler and ruled to know they have in common. | Michael Kinsley, Washington Post

    • Can the Republican Party expand as long as it remains bound to religion? As Kathleen Parker says, the "Republican Party -- and conservatism with it -- eventually will die out unless religion is returned to the privacy of one's heart where it belongs." | Washington Post

    • The totals are in in Florida. And the one with the most write in votes was Hillary Clinton with 234. Jesus got 23 votes, and Willie Nelson 1. Check out the entire list at Ben Smith's Blog. | Politico

    • Obama sends mixed signals on transparency: Does he really want to apply sunlight to the often shadowy depths of the executive branch, or is it merely a very good marketing campaign? | Chris Soghoian/CNET

  • World
    • Heading toward recovery? G-20 summit may not have solved the economic crisis, but it produced a good weekend of world that sets a basis. | The Economist

    • Russian President Dmitry Medvedev gave a state of the nation address the day after the U.S. election, which he said nothing about. He did refer to the United States as being to blame for two problems Russia would not back down from: war in Georgia and the world economic crisis. | The Economist

    • The U.S.-Iraq strike into Syria is yet another dangerous step by the Bush administration. One must hope that the damage will be limited until George W. Bush goes back to his ranch in Texas. | The Daily Star, Lebanon

    • Bombings throughout India should call the government to act agressively against terrorism. | The Times of India

    • The tragedy of Rwanda erupts again in Congo. What needs to be done? | The Economist

 
  • Region
    • Three cheers for Wayne Goode. SE Missourian publishers says it's a critical time for Missouri's budget and Wayne Goode is the right person for the job. | Gary Rust

    • Where's the support for real clean-coal technology? The Illinois Senate should pass a bill that would further research and development of an possible clean-coal plant at Taylorville. | State Journal Register, Springfield, IL

    • Will Illinois listen to its comptroller?  Dan Hynes says the state's backlog of unpaid bills has reached $4 billion. But what are state senators worrying about? A leadership battle. | Springfield State Journal-Register

    • What will the administration of Gov. Jay Nixon mean for Missouri? The Kansas City Star also looks at initiatives that won and lost in that area.

    • The United States may have had good reason to remove North Korea from its list of states that sponsor terrorism, but the decision cause problems for Japan, which had conditioned the delisting on resolving the fate of Japanese kidnapped by North Korea decades ago. | The Japan Times

  • U.S. Elections
    • How did newspapers display the election result? Take a look at a selection. | Robb Montgomery

    • What did the GOP do wrong? The Washington Post gathers thoughts from Ed Rogers, Carter Eskew, Alex Castellanos, Douglas Schoen, Linda Chavez, Geoff Garin, Greg Mueller and Dick Morris.

    • Aftr an election - and before the political battled begin anew - Americans should have one response to the result: Hail to the Chief. | Michael Gerson, townhall.com

    • Oh, oh, it looks as though Missouri's reputation as a bellwether state is about to go away. | Chris Suellentrop in The New York Times

    • The United States just gave America an example of what democracy means and how to conduct an election. | Haaretz , Jerusalem

Jazz with Jerome Harris

Video by Christian Cudnik

Jazz musician and educator Jerome Harris talks about the importance of teaching. See a larger version of this video and read a profile of Harris

Voices

  • In the News

    suburban138chevy.jpgThe Big Three automakers may well be facing drastic, forced reorganization, but they do not have the same compelling case for a government bailout as the financial sector had. Business professor Anjan Thakor explains the difference.

  • In the News

    soa100puppet.jpgPosted 5 p.m. Mon. Nov. 17 - This weekend, nearly a hundred St. Louisans, many of them high school students, will travel to Fort Benning, GA to protest the School of the Americas. Among its graduates are some of Latin America's most notorious dictators, guilty of some of the continent's most savage human rights violations. Rachel Heidenry, who participated in the protest while a student at Nerinx Hall and Bard College, describes the experience and took the photographs that accompany the story and are in a slideshow at the end of the article.

  • In the News

    carter100jimmy.jpg

    In his much-maligned "malaise" speech, President Jimmy Carter spoke of a "crisis of the American spirit" and a Congress paralyzed by special interests. He warned that shared sacrifice had been "abandoned like an orphan without support and without friends." Those warnings hold true. The United States needs to come to terms with its lowered economic position and restore its moral leadership.

  • Beacon Columnists

    credit100card.jpg

    M.W. Guzy notes that a case can be made that the financial problem started when Congress required credit-card companies to charge a minimum payment that actually included principal as well as interest. So, shouldn't Washington get to the root of the problem?

The Lens

Giving Back

The Beacon wants to help you share the news about good deeds St. Louisans are doing. See our spotlight on those who are giving back.

pulitzerheader.jpg

The Beacon features links to the latest work by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting.This Washington-based non-profit organization promotes in-depth international coverage of topics that have been under-reported, mis-reported - or not reported at all.

To see a list on our World news page, click here . The Pulitzer Center's founder is Jon Sawyer, former Washington Bureau chief of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

facebook2.jpg

Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.

twitterbutton100sq.jpg

Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.

mortgageicon.jpg

Mortgage foreclosures are at the heart of the current economic crisis. The Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 have been covering how mortgage problems affect St. Louis area residents.

Visit our special section to read coverage of these issues, watch Channel 9's stories and access resources to find help.

rss75.gif

What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.

RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.

For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.