Saint Louis Beacon

Thursday
Aug 21st
           | 
Home arrow Issues/Politics arrow Arch discussion deadline approaches
Arch discussion deadline approaches Print E-mail
By By Mary Delach Leonard, Beacon staff   
Last Updated ( Friday, 04 July 2008 )
That is our Arch.

So, it's not surprising that area residents are paying a good deal of attention these days to proposals and discussions about what to do with the 91-acre national park the Arch soars above – a site that attracts more than 3 million visitors a year.

With all due respect to Luther Ely Smith who got the idea back in the 1930s to build a memorial to America's pioneer spirit on the city's decaying riverfront, and to the genius of architect Eero Saarinen who designed the still wow-some memorial – and even to the National Park Service that maintains it -- the Arch is ours. An iconic symbol of St. Louis.

Ironically, Mississippi River flooding forced organizers to move the annual Fair St. Louis from the Arch grounds this Fourth of July weekend, just as St. Louisans are getting revved-up about development plans for the national memorial.

Part of the park

courthouse300rh.jpg

Photo by Rachel Heidenry | The Beacon

One of the goals of the new group, Groundswell for Change, is to improve the connectors between the Arch grounds and the Old Courthouse (above).

Regardless, this would be a good time to check out two Websites about the development discussions that grew out of a push to reinvigorate the Arch grounds by local groups, including the Danforth Foundation:

The National Park Service is seeking public input for a future management plan for the memorial. The Park Service has held two public meetings and is accepting comments until July 14 on what it calls "preliminary alternatives" to update a plan that has been in place since the Arch was topped out in 1965.

On July 3, Groundswell for Change, which is pushing for improvements to the St. Louis riverfront and to the Arch grounds, launched the www.groundsforchangestl.org Web site to "educate St. Louisans about a once-in-a-half-century opportunity" to enliven the Arch grounds and connect them better to downtown St. Louis.

The broad-based bi-state group has formed a steering committee of government leaders, citizens, civic, business, labor and disability rights groups to urge the Park Service to make what it calls two key improvements to the Jefferson National Expansion Memorial, which also includes the Old Courthouse:

  • A major, above-ground destination attraction, such as a museum, on the Arch grounds.
  • Improved pedestrian connectors between the Arch grounds and the riverfront and between downtown and the Old Courthouse.

"By making some key enhancements leading to and on the Arch grounds, we can connect those grounds and the riverfront to downtown and realize Eero Saarinen's original dream of having a magnificent monument complemented by museums, restaurants and other attractions. We would make the Jefferson National Expansion Memorial a more complete experience for visitors, and we would make the whole St. Louis region a more compelling destination,'' said Kitty Ratcliffe, a steering committee member, in a news release. Ratcliffe is also president of the St. Louis Convention and Visitors Commission.

The Web site includes research and videos, a list of members and also encourages area residents to join the group and to lobby the National Park Service.

Contact Beacon staff writer Mary Delach Leonard.

  To read previous Beacon stories about the Arch click Dramatic changes considered for the Arch or Sen. Danforth's statement on the Arch or Recommendations for the Arch or Hope for a better Arch or New Arch superintendent, or Public meetings planned or Arch grounds, change or not?

 

 
Discuss (1 posts)
Arch discussion deadline approaches
Jul 07 2008 02:33:43
This thread discusses the Content article: Arch discussion deadline approaches

A connector between the Arch and Downtown is long overdue. But the introduction of this other issue - the "passivity of the Arch grounds" - is an unfortunate distraction.

We don't need to build anything on the arch grounds. And if St. Louis has the money and the talent for the creation of a new museum, then let's put in Grand Center or Washington Ave. or some other neighborhood which is struggling to create a lively everyday environment.

Why we don't need another "attraction" on the Arch grounds:

1. The Arch already gets plenty of visitors! It's simply not true that the Arch is a failure as a public attraction. A friend of mine at the Arch used to say they got 3.5 million visitors per year. Wiki Online right now says it's 4 million. Even if the numbers have been falling the past few years, so what? Folks still come from all over the country to see this thing, to go to the museum, to go up top.

The problem isn't getting visitors to the Arch grounds. The problem is getting visitors to the Arch to do something more in St. Louis!

2. Isolated attractions almost never work for purposes of urban planning. Central Park and Millenium Park are successful generators of urban excitement because they are so well integrated into the surrounding city. Neighborhoods including housing, offices, hotels, libraries, bookstores, and restaurants are all within close proximity and easy to get to. New Yorkers never tire of going to Central Park because it's so beautiful AND accessible. Make the Arch grounds accessible, and St. Louisians will flock there as well.

3. The Arch grounds are beautiful and peaceful. Why is that a problem? What would we gain as a city if an additional million people visited the Arch and then stampeded around the grounds buying tacky photos and models of the monument? Nada.

4. We should get going on the connector, fix up Kiener Plaza, do something with the hideous parking garages lining the plaza, improve the Old Courthouse, improve the Soldiers Memorial, put some housing and amenities in that section of downtown and THEN see if we really need to tinker with the Archgrounds. Those other points are no-brainers. Let's start there!
#59

Discuss this item on the forums. (1 posts)

Editors' Picks

 

Manufacturing harmony: Wicks Organs

Read the story and see a larger version of this slideshow

Voices in the news

  • vote100.jpgWhether by old-line boys on the bus or hot-shot bloggers, elections are covered like a horse race: Who's ahead? What are the odds? But the old-time journalistm was pretty straightforward, giving just what the candidate said. Now, cable and others mix analysis with the facts, and opinions are freely offered. Is the electorate confused or enlightened? Retired professor Lana Stein raises questions she hopes people will study.

Columnists

  • guzy100.jpgColumnist M.W. Guzy remembers a time when conventions actually mattered. As the Democrats and Republicans return to the "nominating" arena with everything carefully orchestrated, he wonders what the ratings will be for Nick at Nite. 

Blogs

  • Law Scoop

    Sen. Barack Obama told Pastor Rick Warren at the Saddleback Church forum that he wouldn't have appointed Clarence Thomas to the Supreme Court, partly because of inexperience. Conservatives responded, charging that Obama is less qualified than Justice Thomas.

The Lens


heliumplusbeacon200sq.jpg

The Beacon, through Helium.com, invites writers to respond to questions we pose on timely topics. Winning articles appear in the Beacon. 

To see the latest winner, read "Reduce the stigma of reporting medical errors "   

Our next topic: Read "Nearly naked in the St. Louis night" and write about your impression of St. Louis. For details, visit Helium.

facebook2.jpg

Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.

twitterbutton100sq.jpg

Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.

mortgageicon.jpg

The Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 are covering mortgage forclosures – how they're affecting St. Louis area residents and where you can find help. 

Visit our special section to read coverage of this issue, watch Channel 9's stories and access resources to find help.

rss75.gif

What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.

RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.

For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.