St. Louis Beacon

  • Kira Backs The Beacon
Tuesday
Feb 07th






      
 
Home

Cialis Online

The color wheel: Rooted in history, colorism still causes prejudice based on skin tone Print E-mail
By Kristen Hare, Beacon staff   
Posted 6:00 pm Thu., 1.28.10
Posted 1:20 p.m. Fri., 01.29.10 - Growing up in Selma, Ala., Pamela Jackson used to sing a song.

"If you're yellow, you mellow. If you're brown, hang around. If you're black, step back. If you're white, you're all right."

She knew what it meant, she always did. But understanding colorism, or the preference or prejudice showed to people of color depending on the lightness or darkness of their skin, is one thing. Talking about it is another.

jackson150pamela.jpg After Jackson (right) remembers the song, a friend calls on the other line and Jackson switches over for a moment. When she switches back, she says her friend thinks that's stupid, an ignorant question. 

Her friend calls Jackson back, and says she has something to say, too.

When reached, that friend doesn't want her name used because of her job, but she thinks colorism is a non-subject, a small piece in a bigger problem -- racism. She thinks the historical roots of colorism are ignored, and that hearing about it within the black community can cause white people to abdicate their own responsibilities.

Jackson disagrees, at least about the non-subject part.

"I don't think that it doesn't exist. We know it exists," she says. "We are inhibited and afraid to talk about it."

HOUSE OR FIELD

A 2005 working paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research examined both the history of colorism and how it affected the household wealth of 15,000 households during the 1860 census. In the urban South, they found major differences in wealth among white, bi-racial and black households.

"For many of African descent, black is not black -- both in terms of how they view themselves and how others view them. There are meaningful subtleties of shade, differences that have socially and politically meaningful distinctions today -- just as they have in the past."

The paper, "Colorism and African American Wealth," also notes that while we tend to define people as either black or white, that dichotomy ignores the children produced from white slave owners and their black slaves. To understand the impact of lighter skin, the research separates people into black, white and bi-racial, or mulatto, as they put it.

During slavery, the report says, people of color with lighter skin often got preferential treatment from slave owners, working in the home instead of the fields.

parameswaran150radhika.jpg "So that colorism within the black or African American community became about class or associations with whiteness," says Radhika Parameswaran (right), an associate professor of journalism at Indiana University, who studied colorism in India.

And often, NBER's paper reports, slave owners included their house slaves in their wills.

People with lighter skin had better access to education, and in the antebellum South, better jobs.

This persisted through the Civil War, but the paper notes that Jim Crow laws and the one-drop rule politically and socially brought bi-racial and black people together. (The so-called "one-drop rule" labeled an individual black who had even "one drop of black blood.") Still, the preference shown to people with lighter skin continued and studies on color stratification were done during the 1930s and 1940s, which found that "light skin tones and perceptible traces of non-African heritage were associated with material advantages for African Americans."

Finally, they report on an analysis done in 2000, which shows that light-complected men are more than twice as likely to find "high-prestige employment" than dark-complected men.

FROM THERE TO HERE

Jackson's grandmother and her grandmother's sisters were very fair. They could pass as white, she says. Her grandmother married a dark-complected black man and was ostracized from her family and told she wouldn't prosper.

Jackson, a nurse and instructor in gerontology at Washington University's School of Medicine, thinks that her family has grown out of that way of thinking, but doesn't think it's completely out of our culture yet.

"It still exists," she says. "It's just that people don't address it as much."

deibel150kersha.jpg Kersha Deibel (right), a grad student, wanted to understand the roots of colorism. In a 20-page-paper, "The Invisible Plantation," Deibel found both the historic roots of preference for lighter skin and its many manifestations.

"I always have seen the battle between light skin and dark skin," says Deibel, who is biracial, white and black. Deibel has long, curly hair, and has always been told by hair dressers that she has "good" hair, which frustrates her.

In her paper, Deibel makes note of black social organizations like Jack and Jill of America, and black Greek organizations on college campuses that preferred light-complected black members and used the brown paper bag test, refusing admittance if someone was darker than the bag.

"These organizations provided benefits such as networking and leadership skills," Deibel writes. "Light-skinned blacks continued to uphold these standards and elite positions within the organizations, therefore faring much better than their dark-skinned counterparts."

Now, she even sees colorism on Twitter, where she often finds trending topics of light skin vs. dark skin. She sees it in the media, where white beauty standards are the norm, and light-skinned black actresses seem to dominate.

But that's not just true in America.

race300.gif

In St. Louis, race affects politics, the economy, personal relationships, education – virtually every important aspect of community life. Yet it’s difficult to talk honestly and productively about race. In Race, Frankly, the Beacon invites you to look at race with fresh eyes. It’s a new day nationally, and in St. Louis, it’s time.

Read more stories in the Race, Frankly project

Parameswaran, the journalism professor from Indiana University, spent seven years studying colorism in India along with a partner. In her study, "Melanin on the Margins," she explored the world of advertising in India, where skin-lightening products make up between 40 and 50 percent of the market.

And she found the push for lighter skin went far beyond ads.

Lighter-skinned actresses appear in Bollywood movies, and matrimonial ads for arranged marriages express bold preferences for lighter skinned women.

"When you put everything together, then it's not just advertising," she says, "but it becomes a strong message in the culture."

Parameswaran found colorism in Malaysia, Thailand, Japan, China and the U.S.

And she has had her own experiences with it, too.

Parameswaran grew up in India with both subtle and strong messages about her skin tone. She had a friend also named Radhika, and when they were together, the friend was light Radhika and Parameswaran was dark Radhika. Luckily for her, she says, she had educated parents who told her that value based on skin tone was nonsense.

Based on her own life and her research, Parameswaran thinks it's important to understand colorism from a global perspective. Colorism within one's own group can easily translate to racism and discrimination when in the larger society, especially when those people are foreigners, she says. If East Indians are socialized to see light skin as more desirable, then they'll translate those preferences to other races, too.

"Colorism is very portable," she says. "And it comes with people and then it affects the relations."

THE REAL POWER

With all the weight given to skin tone, Anna Shabsin thinks colorism gives its real power to the majority -- white people.

inform our coverage

This article contains information gathered with the help of our Public Insight Network.

The St. Louis Beacon, in partnership with KETC/Channel 9, is using this journalism tool to help us solicit knowledge and insight from people who become sources through the Network.
 
To learn about the Network and how you can become a source, please click here.

"It only helps the person or the group in power," says Shabsin, a lecturer in the Brown School of Social Work at Washington University.

"The majority sets the tone," Jackson agrees. "And then the minority implements it."

Shabsin teaches several courses on diversity and says that when white people see colorism expressed within a minority community, it's easy for them to relinquish their own responsibilities with social justice, thinking, if they can't handle it, why should I?

Also, Parameswaran says, the problem with trying to deal with colorism in a larger setting is that it can easily distract people from the real issue of racism.

For those reasons, Deibel thinks many black people are reluctant to talk about it.

"They don't want this to come out," she says. "They don't want people to know that there are issues occurring within our community."

Parameswaran thinks the real work combating colorism has to be done within a community. In India, that begins with simply naming the issue, but in America, she says, there is at least an awareness of it. Here, she thinks, colorism should be talked about in churches, colleges and places where the black community can work together.

Deibel also thinks the media could play a big role in changing the stereotypical images of dark-skinned black men and women. In her paper, she wrote: "These images, which are constantly seen as negative, must be changed into positive images and not portray stereotypical roles, such as criminals, convicts, and mammies."

In India, colorism affects women the most, but with globalization, beauty companies are starting to target men.

In America, "it probably affects women more visibly, I'd say that," says Shabsin, because women are usually judged visually on their looks and size.

But you don't have to think hard to find an example of colorism among men, she adds.

"You had it with Harry Reid's comment about Obama being a light-skinned black man," she says.

Inversely, Jackson thinks black men often choose lighter-skinned women for wives, again showing preference for white beauty standards, and that work needs to be done with them, too.

While there was the "Black is Beautiful" movement in the 1970s, trumpeting the natural beauty and features of people of color, now there are calls for both self-acceptance and the redefinition of beauty standards many places online, including a Facebook page called "Sisters against colorism and the brothers that support them." In one discussion thread about combating colorism, members disagree about whether change should start at the top, in the media, or closer to the ground, with themselves.

Either way, Jackson thinks it's still an issue, even if her friend doesn't.

"I think it still exists," she says. "But that's OK for us to agree to disagree."

Contact Beacon reporter Kristen Hare.

 

 

Only registered users can comment on an article. Please login or register.

  • Thank you for reading the St. Louis Beacon, a non-profit news organization dedicated to reporting and discussing "news that matters" to the St. Louis region. You can support the Beacon by attending our events, becoming a source in our Public Insight Network or making a donation.

Editors' Picks

 

'The Road Show' improv

Brent Jones | St. Louis Beacon

This Saturday was the debut of a new show by The Improv Shop that will bring out of town improv teams to St. Louis to play for — and with — a local audience. The Road Show brought teams "Everybody Grok" and "Felt" from Chicago.

We talked to Eric Christensen, producer of the Road Show and member of local improv team "Ted Dangerous"; Katie Nunn, member of "Ted Dangerous" and improv coach; and Melanie Penn and Ranjan Khan, members of local teams "Melanj" and "Magic Ratio"; about the St. Louis improv scene and why it's important to welcome teams from other cities to perform here.

See a larger version of the slideshow

Topics

  • meachampark

    Separating myths and realities about Meacham Park

    Kirkwood resident and Beacon contributor William Freivogel opened our series on Kirkwood's Journey, a look at Kirkwood's efforts to understand how race affects the city since the deadly city hall shooting in 2008. This piece, part one of two, looks at the Meacham Park and misconceptions.

Voices

  • M.W. Guzy fears his daughters' affection for trash TV might have been genetically inherited, as he finds himself drawn to the anybody-but-Mitt show, playing on a loop on cable "news' channels.

  • Miguel Dulick recounts a trans-Honduras tour that, again, reminded him of the power and joy of keeping siblings and parents connected.

  • Ken Schechtman says that publicly traded business will not -- perhaps cannot -- put doing the right thing ahead of legally maximizing profits.

Beacon Roundtable

Beacon Blog

On chess


@

Register to receive our daily email of new content.  If you're already registered, email us at [email protected] with the subject line "subscribe".

Barroom Conversations

The Beacon's nationally recognized Barroom Conversations program on race, class and other issues that divide will be held on Monday, Feb. 20, 2012, at 7:30 PM discussing Education and Class. RSVP on Facebook and invite your friends! We'll pick up where we left off at Six Row Brewing Co., 3690 Forest Park Avenue at Spring. We look forward to seeing you again!

mikado

The MIKADO has a little list … were you on it?

The St. Louis Beacon rang in 2012 with a concert performance of Gilbert & Sullivan's beloved operetta, "The Mikado," at the Sheldon Concert Hall, and the Higher Education Channel was on hand to record it. Here is a link to the complete perfomance, which we hope you'll enjoy.

 The musical direction of "The Mikado" was by Amy Kaiser; Craig Terry was conductor-accompanist. All proceeds from ticket sales benefitted the Beacon.
FAcebook
Twitter
Google+
RSS
inn_125x125_white_rounded_square2

The Investigative News Network is a consortium of nonprofit news organizations dedicated to watchdog and public interest reporting.

See our other partners.