| Take Five: Patricia Tummons on environmental legacy of Lewis Green |
|
|
| By Elia Powers, Beacon staff | |
| Posted 10:47 am Thu., 01.14.10 | |
|
"Litigation is not for the faint of heart," prominent St. Louis environmental lawyer Lewis C. Green once wrote. Green is the subject of a new book, "A Force for Nature: The Environmental Litigation of Lewis C. Green," by Patricia Tummons and Florence Shinkle, both former reporters and editors with the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. The book provides blow-by-blow accounts of some of the region's most memorable environmental cases, and makes it clear that Green didn't shy away from protracted, highly divisive legal battles. Green fought the Environmental Protection Agency over enforcement of the federal Clean Air Act and Union Electric Co. over its sulfur emissions. He challenged the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on the environmental safety of controversial development plans. He was a central figure in the lengthy dispute over land use at Queeny Park and became an ardent opponent of plans to build a football stadium in the floodplain of the Missouri Bottoms. 'a force for nature' What: Book signing with co-authors Patricia Tummons and Florence Shinkle
When: 5 p.m., Fri., Jan. 15
Where: 11 Litzsinger Lane
How much: Free, but reservations are required by calling 314-231-4181 by end-of-day Thursday.
A St. Louis native, Green first made his name in local Democratic Party politics, and in 1965 was appointed by then-Gov. Warren Hearnes to become the first chairman of the Missouri Air Conservation Commission, an agency that adopted clean air regulations for St. Louis, a city once known for its coal smoke. (This was well before the Clean Air Act was in place.) Green was a founding member of the Missouri Coalition for the Environment and often represented the group in legal disputes. Shortly before his death in 2003, he donated $600,000 to start the Great Rivers Environmental Law Center, a nonprofit firm that does public interest environmental litigation. (Green's daughter and longtime legal partner are among the lawyers who continue to advocate for environmental causes.) The Beacon spoke with Tummons Wednesday about the book. Here's a condensed version of our conversation. What was your interest in looking back at the life of Lewis Green?
Photo by Elia Powers | St. Louis Beacon Patricia Tummons (left) and Florence Shinkle Tummons: When I was writing editorials for the Post-Dispatch, I came to know Lewis. Then I came to also know him personally because I got invited to something called the Wednesday Lawyers' Lunch. This was an institution that was made up of mainly middle-aged and older men, most of whom were lawyers, all of whom were of a liberal frame of mind. Florence then joined the lunch group, and that's how the two of us got to know him. Mrs. Green approached Florence asking her to do something about the major cases that Lewis handled so that his grandchildren had an idea of the important work that he did. We were struck by the range of his work, the importance of his work, starting really coincident with the very earliest federal environmental laws. We thought that was an amazing opportunity to make this available for the broader public. My sense from reading the book is that Green viewed the environmental laws as just the start. He seemed focused on the battles over how these measures were enforced. Tummons: That's right. He got a hold of something and wouldn't let go. I think he recognized that the laws were the open door to enforcement and if you had no enforcement than you have litigation, and so he was willing to go the administrative route to seek enforcement, but if that enforcement wasn't made by the agencies responsible, the courts were the next step. He never shied away from a court battle. On the other hand, he never regarded litigation as the first step. And as you'll read in the book, he wasn't batting 1,000 in the courts. It's certainly true that Green rarely got everything he wanted in legal disputes, but he rarely got nothing, either. Being in that middle ground, how did he measure success? Tummons: The success is in the eye of the beholder. There were clear-cut successes, as in the case of Fort Leonard Wood (in which the U.S. Army had decided to move its chemical warfare training facility from Alabama to Missouri. Opponents, like Green, worried about potential discharges into streams and waste processing, among other things.) In the sense of interpretation of clean water laws, it went to the Missouri Supreme Court and there was a really clear decision that has far-ranging impacts that you do not have to be only an adjacent land owner to challenge a permit for pollution that would be given by the state. (The court overturned a previous decision that had effectively denied third parties from challenging permits issued under the state's clean water law). That's a really powerful and important decision. On the other hand, the installation at Fort Leonard Wood that was the object of all of this litigation went forward (the facility ended up moving), so maybe that was a defeat. You have to look very carefully to determine if something is a victory or setback. The name Great Rivers Environmental Law Center indicates that safeguarding the water was at the top of Green's agenda. To what extent was this true, and what about clean air litigation? Tummons: He was an avid canoer; he loved the wild and the water. He wasn't just an armchair environmentalist. Not only did he love the free-flowing waters, but he also had such respect for the need to be deferential to the laws of nature. If you are going to build on flood plains, expect to be flooded. And he didn't think that flood plains were appropriate for building sites. There again there are mixed victories -- Earth City is pretty well built up at this point. It's hard to remember when Gumbo (now the site of Chesterfield Commons) was a flood plain. Nonetheless, some outcomes are still being defended today. His work to protect the air bookends his career. He starts with clean air ligitation against Union Electric. And he ends with clean air litigation against the EPA. I think that concern grew out of his tenure as the first chairman of the Missouri Air Conservation Commission. I think it's appropriate that clean air would be on either end of his career as an environmental litigator. What's the environmental issue now that he would feel most strongly about? Tummons: One of the things that amazed me was reading back through testimony he gave in 1969 to a Congressional committee headed by Sen. (Thomas) Eagleton on clean air. He started talking about global warming. That was a time when carbon dioxide was beginning to be seen as a potential agent to warm the atmosphere, and Lewis mentioned that. Right now if he was litigating he'd be out there trying to get controls on CO2 emissions. Contact Beacon reporter Elia Powers.
|
Rick Riordan will read from his work and sign books in an appearance at MICDS, 101 N. Warson Rd., at 7 p.m. Oct. 14. Free, but tickets required. slclfoundation.wordpress.com/
Ellen Hopkins, author of the Crank teen series will discuss the latest installment in the trilogy, "Fallout," at 7 p.m. Sept. 20 at the St. Louis Country Library Headquarters, 1640 S. Lindbergh Blvd. Free.
Thomas Danisi will discuss his book “Meriwether Lewis” at 2 p.m. Sept. 21, at the Grand Glaize Branch of St. Louis County Library, 1010 Meramec Station Rd., Manchester. The book focuses on Lewis’ pre-expedition and post-expedition life.
Don DeLillo to receive St. Louis Literary Award: He joins the company of past winners including Salman Rushdie, John Updike, William Gass, Joyce Carol Oates, Joan Didion and Tennessee Williams. | STLtoday
Immediacy Theatre Project holds a "Drawn and Quartered" series at Mad Art Gallery , 2727 South 12th St., July 30 and 31, Aug. 20 and 21, Sept. 23 and 24, and Oct. 29 and 30. Each month offers 35 new two-minute plays. Doors open at 7 p.m.; shows start at 8. $8 at the door.
Top Tony awards go to "Red," "Memphis": Big-name winners included Denzel Washington, Catherine Zeta-Jones, Scarlett Johansson and Viola Davis. | New York Times
The 2010-11 International Performing Arts Series at the Touhill will feature Chinese Dance; Mavrothi Kontanis and the Maeandros Ensemble; Taikoza; Chiwoniso: Rebel Woman, and Triptych. Subscriptions available now; single tickets Aug. 9. http://www.touhill.org
"Fela!" and "La Cage" pick up 11 Tony nominations each: Broadway veteran Jan Maxwell pulled off a rare feat, scoring double honors as a nominee for lead actress in a play (“The Royal Family”) and for featured actress in a play (“Lend Me a Tenor”). | New York Times
The first performance in the stylus concert series at the Pulitzer Foundation for the Arts, 3716 Washington, will take place at 7:30 p.m. Sept. 14 & 15. Kurtag's Kafka-Fragmente, op. 24 will be performed by soprano Susan Narucki and violinist David Halen. Doors open at 7 p.m. Tickets, $10-$20, can be purchased through the Symphony .
Arianna String Quartet kicks off 2010-11 concert series at 8 p.m. Sept. 10 at the E. Desmond & Mary Ann Lee Theater at the Touhill with works by Dvoak, Shostakovich and Schubert. $23. www.touhill.org or 314-516-4949.
Nikki Washington will sing the songs of Dinah Washington from 3-6 p.m. Sept. 4 at the Metropolitan Gallery, 2936 Locust St. Information: 314-535-6500 http://www.thenu-artseries.org .
Nelly is scheduled to fill in for DJ Staci Static on Hot 104.1 FM during drive time. The maternity leave special replacement is only set to last for a month. | HipHopDX
Have "Coffee with the Presidents" -- Peter Wyse Jackson and Peter H. Raven, that is -- from 9-10:30 a.m., Sept. 25. at the Missouri Botanical Garden, 4344 Shaw Blvd. www.mobot.org
The Endangered Wolf Center, Washington University's Tyson Research Center (6750 Tyson Valley Road, Eureka), will hold an open house from 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Sept. 19. $15 a carload. Photo opportunities and entertainment will be available.
The 9th annual Green Homes Festival will be from 10 a.m.-6 p.m. Sept. 25 at the Missouri Botanical Garden's EarthWays Center in the 3600 block of Grandel Square.
Celebrate the 20th anniversary of the Katy Trail with a Father's Day (June 20) bike ride to benefit prostate cancer research at the Siteman Cancer Center. The ride will begin between 8 a.m. and 1 p.m. at several points along the Katy Trail and will end in Defiance, Mo. $10-$15. www.fathersdaybikeride.com/
The Nu-Art Series will present "Paintings by Cbabi Bayoc" from 6-9 p.m. Sept. 3 at the Metropolitan Gallery, 2936 Locust St. The show continues through Oct. 2, Wednesday - Friday, 11 a.m. to 5 p.m. Information: 314-535-6500 www.thenu-artseries.org .
Performance artist Tom Brady offers "Emozioni Ricordati (Recalled Emotions)" at 8 p.m. Sept. 16-18 and 23-25 at Satori, 3003 Locust St. Tickets: aartser.eventbrite.com/
A show by Kit Keith, “New and Used,” will open with a reception from 6-8 p.m. Sept. 10 at William Shearburn Gallery , 4735 McPherson Ave. The exhibit will run through Oct. 16.
The Foundry Art Centre, 520 N. Main Center, St. Charles, hosts an opening reception from 5-9 p.m., Aug. 27 of "The Artful Palette," a juried painting exhibit. The show runs through Oct. 8
First-timers break through to win Emmys: Shows like "Glee," "Modern Family" and "Nurse Jackie" garnered awards along with older favorites. | Los Angeles Times
Kurt Warner will compete on "Dancing With the Stars": The former Ram would be the first quarterback to take part in the show. | Washington Post
Emmy nominations led by "The Pacific" with 24 and "Glee" with 19: HBO dominated the nominations with 101, two more than last year's haul. | Los Angeles Times
"Golden Girl" Rue McClanahan dies at age 76: The Emmy-winning actress suffered a brain hemorrhage. | AP
Drew Canning talks with island residents Courtney "Manny" Brown and Dorothy "Dot" Brown, who recall what life used to be like on Kaskaskia Island. To read more about the island and see a larger version of the slideshow, click here .(Photos by Rachel Heidenry | Beacon intern)
Planning for a trip to Mongolia, even if you already in Dalian, China, must be undertaken with care -- particularly when Woodson Gannaway plans to spend no more than $550.
Kira Hudson Banks asks whether the rally was meant to "reclaim" civil rights or dismiss them?
Rep. Todd Akin, Republican incumbent in the 2nd district, discusses specific areas, such as nuclear policy, terrorism and the way in Afghanistan, in which he disagrees with the administration's policies .
Arthur Lieber, Democratic candidate in the 2nd district, focuses on how decisions are made and seven principles, such as no will be deployed without equipment that gives them maximum safety .
In this week's Beacon Roundtable, Dick Weiss, Robert Joiner, Dale Singer and Jo Mannies sit down to talk about a setback for stem-cell research, the elected school board of St.…
Read more...Editor Margaret Wolf Freivogel discusses why combat troups in Iraq and a Muslim cultural center in Manhattan are news that matters for a regional news source.
Read more...The film studios have to be fatigued from the ups and downs of another cycle of Summer! Movie! Blockbusters! Certainly, filmgoers have had enough of less-than super heroes.
@
Register to receive our daily email of new content. If you're already registered, email us at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it with the subject line "subscribe".
The St. Louis Beacon sponsors every-other-weekly conversations on race, related to the publication's year-long special coverage of issues and situations related to race in the St. Louis region. The lightly-moderated discussions begin with a specific topic, but like all good conversations, veer off in different and rewarding directions. The Barroom Conversations are on summer break, and will resume in September. We look forward to seeing regulars and newcomers when the break is over. Everyone is welcome.
Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.
Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.
In St. Louis, race affects virtually every important aspect of community life. Yet it’s difficult to talk productively about race. Race, Frankly invites you to look at race with fresh eyes.
The Missouri History Museum, the Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 have partnered to create a yearlong series of events, in-depth articles and video pieces.
What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.
RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.
For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.