| Health check (Part 5): Baucus bill may test the limits of the politically possible |
|
|
| By Harry Levins, Special to the Beacon |
| Posted 7:00 pm Thu., 10.15.09 |
|
For all the sound and fury about President Barack Obama's plan to overhaul health care, one curious fact stands out: Obama has no plan of his own. The White House was wary of repeating the blunder of President Bill Clinton. In 1993, Clinton dumped a detailed health-care bill onto Congress -- and watched in dismay as his 1,342-page plan sank of its own weight.
Obama listed some broad outlines. But he left to Congress the chore of writing the bill itself, with all of its touchy details. Three committees in the House and two in the Senate have come up with health-care plans. But most of the attention has gone to the bill in the Senate Finance Committee, headed by Democrat Max Baucus of Montana. Why so much attention to the Senate Finance Committee? First, that bill pays for itself, with a bit left over. Second, Democrats hold a big edge in the House. But in the Senate, they have just barely enough seats to foil a filibuster. So the Senate Finance Committee's bill probably bumps up against the limit of what's politically possible. At any rate, much wheeling and dealing remains to be wheeled and dealt. The two Senate bills must be wrestled into a single bill. So must the three House bills. And then, the final Senate bill will have to be meshed with whatever the House produces as its final bill. But for now, the spotlight is on the Senate Finance Committee's bill. Here's a rundown on what's in that bill. The missing links Just as important as what's in the Senate Finance Committee's bill are two items that are not in it -- a public option and an employer mandate. (Still, both are in the other Senate bill, passed by the Senate Health committee.) A public option is simply a health insurance plan run by the federal government, competing against the private, for-profit insurers who now rule the market. Americans who are priced out of the insurance market could get public-option insurance more cheaply. After all, unlike the private insurers, the government could drop profit from the price of its premiums. Conservative Republicans see a public-option plan as the first step toward a government takeover of health care -- as the nose in the tent for "socialized medicine." In the Senate, the conservatives have allies among Democratic centrists wary of a public option. Although the politically savvy Obama calls a public option a plus, he has now stopped short of calling it vital. The plan that came out of Baucus' committee lacks a public option, much to the distress of liberal Democrats.
Many big businesses bristle at the price tag for health insurance. As politician-physician Howard Dean notes, General Motors spends more per car for health insurance than it does for steel, while Starbucks pays more for health insurance than it does for coffee beans. A growing number of small businesses have simply dropped health insurance altogether. Instead of an employer mandate, the Senate bill imposes an individual mandate -- a requirement that everybody (or almost everybody) buy insurance. Those who balk would pay a penalty. Comparison-shopping To help individuals sort through the confusing mass of insurance plans, the Senate Finance bill sets up state-by-state "exchanges." In effect, these marketplaces would let people comparison-shop, balancing what competing plans offer against what they cost. The government would set the rules on what benefits all plans for sale on the exchanges must offer -- for example, preventive and primary care, emergency service, hospital stays, prescription drugs and so on. In a big change from the way things work now, insurers would have to offer their plans to people who are already sick -- who have what the trade calls "pre-existing conditions." Nor could the insurers drop policyholders who get sick. And the private insurers would be barred from putting yearly or lifetime limits on just how much health care they'll pay for. To dampen the demand by liberals for a public option, the bill would boost the income cap for getting into Medicaid, the health program for the poorest of Americans. And the bill would allow "co-ops" of health insurance buyers. In theory, anyway, by banding together in cooperatives, individuals and small businesses would gain the clout they need to drive better bargains with insurers. To help low- and middle-income people shopping in the exchanges, the government would offer tax credits on a sliding scale. They'd apply to families earning up to $88,000 a year. Similarly, the Senate Finance bill offers a range of tax credits to small businesses that shop for insurance at the exchanges. For some, the credit could eventually total half of the total they spend. On the down side, the bill slaps a tax on so-called "Cadillac policies" -- gold-plated insurance with a steep yearly premium. In theory, the insurers would pay the tax. In practice, they'll tack it on to the cost of the premium. Some labor unions have contracts calling for Cadillac policies, in part the result of trading wage increases for health benefits. They're upset, and then some, at the prospect of seeing a worker's share of his premium taxed. On the other hand, big businesses that refuse to offer health insurance to their workers would have to kick in to the government up to $400 a year for each worker who got a federal subsidy to buy his or her own coverage. Harry and Louise: The Encore When Obama stood before Congress, he insisted that he'd stand in the way of any health-care plan "that adds one dime to the deficit." More health coverage
|
Brent Jones | St. Louis Beacon
This Saturday was the debut of a new show by The Improv Shop that will bring out of town improv teams to St. Louis to play for — and with — a local audience. The Road Show brought teams "Everybody Grok" and "Felt" from Chicago.
We talked to Eric Christensen, producer of the Road Show and member of local improv team "Ted Dangerous"; Katie Nunn, member of "Ted Dangerous" and improv coach; and Melanie Penn and Ranjan Khan, members of local teams "Melanj" and "Magic Ratio"; about the St. Louis improv scene and why it's important to welcome teams from other cities to perform here.
Who owns this field of dreams?
Baseball may be the national pastime, the field of dreams that "reminds us of all that once was good," but it also reflects -- and sometimes anticipates -- the country's social and economic changes. This story is part of a larger look at class in the region, our series Class: The Great Divide
M.W. Guzy fears his daughters' affection for trash TV might have been genetically inherited, as he finds himself drawn to the anybody-but-Mitt show, playing on a loop on cable "news' channels.
Miguel Dulick recounts a trans-Honduras tour that, again, reminded him of the power and joy of keeping siblings and parents connected.
Ken Schechtman says that publicly traded business will not -- perhaps cannot -- put doing the right thing ahead of legally maximizing profits.
In this week's Beacon Roundtable, Dick Weiss, Jason Rosenbaum, Jo Mannies, Robert Joiner and Dale Singer sit down to talk about the Missouri primary and redistricting, the controversy around…
General manager Nicole Hollway is back to the Beacon blog and she's trying to piece together what social media is and means to people.
Ben Finegold checks out the women's play at the Tradewise Gilbraltar Chess Congress, particularly the chess played by 17-year-old Hou Yifan of China.
@
Register to receive our daily email of new content. If you're already registered, email us at [email protected] with the subject line "subscribe".
The Missouri Foundation for Health will hold a meeting to highlight its funding strategy for 2012. The meeting is scheduled for 9-11 a.m. on February 1 at the Missouri Foundation for Health's 2nd floor training room in the Grand Central building at Union Station in St. Louis.
Meetings are free and designed for health and community action nonprofits, community service clubs, human service providers and community leaders. RSVPs are encouraged: Contact Maranda Witherspoon at 800-655-5560 or [email protected]. More information.