| Reforming the reform: Locals in health care discuss industry's biggest problems and how to fix them |
|
|
| By Kristen Hare, Beacon staff |
| Posted 9:52 am Tue., 8.4.09 |
|
Right now, health-care reform is right at the top of the national agenda. Local, state and national politicians are setting up camp around issues important to them. They hold press conferences and release numbers. Interest groups -- ranging from business to drug companies -- are lobbying Congress. But what about the people who work in the trenches of health care? The emergency room doctor, the hospital administrator, the home health care nurse, the physical therapist, the family doctor, the specialist? For each, a specific problem tops the list, and often, those problems intersect. Efficiency, for example, was mentioned nearly to a person. Most medical professionals felt that time and money are wasted on duplicating tests. Effective communication between institutions and professions occurs rarely, and usually, it's the patients who suffer. Some people we spoke with have ideas on what needs to be done. Others just know something needs to be done. Perhaps the only thing that all can agree on? "I don't think it can continue like this," says Dr. Karen Webb, chief medical officer with Saint Louis University Hospital. Dr. Jay Moore POSITION: Family doctor, St. Charles Clinic Medical Group, Wentzville, Medical Director for Quality and Process Improvement, SSMPO ISSUES: The uninsured and underinsured
"The reason we see so many is that there aren't many doctors who takeMedicaid, and so those of us who do are swamped," he says. "We have toturn patients away every day because I can't afford to see any more." Also, it's hard to get specialized care for theuninsured and underinsured, he says, and "I wind up having to treatpatients for things I've never really trained to treat." Take a patient with seizures, for example. Special tests are needed,and then medications. If a person is uninsured or underinsured, hewon't be able to get in to see a specialist. Moore then has to orderthe tests and monitor the patient and the response to the medication. Read more from the Beacon: Small business is grappling with a huge problem: health care for employees Cheers, jeers erupt as St. Louisans tell Carnahan of their health care concerns Blunt and Durbin are the biggest area players in national health-care debate Where does it hurt? Opinions on health reform can be driven by personal experience Health-care system is sick, but no one treatment will cure it HIPAA, huh? A glossary of health-care terms An interview with Kathleen Sebelius on heatlh-care costs and health-care reforms Rep. Blunt's health-care role in GOP Akin lambastes health-care and cap-and-trade legislation at forum From the New York Times: A comparison of House and Senate bills "I'm an internist, not a neurologist, and I'm not always comfortabledoing this. But what choice is there? If I don't take care of thepatient, they aren't going to get care at all. So, I explain to thepatient that it's not my field, but I'm doing my best. The patient getssubstandard care that is probably more expensive than it needs to be,because I can't get the patient in to see a specialist." Another problem for people who don't have insuranceor don't have enough insurance is not getting in to see doctors at all.Over time, a small problem builds into a big, sometimes chronic one. And often, Moore says, people can't get treatmentin the earliest stages, when their conditions are easiest and cheapestto treat, because of insurance. Those people eventually end up in theE.R., where legally they can't be turned away. There, they get lots oftests and are usually seen quickly. That, he says, ends up costing moremoney, and when those people can't pay their medical bills, thehospital's costs go up for everyone. In 2007, the U.S. Census Bureau reported 45.7million people under 65 were uninsured. According to the Kaiser FamilyFoundation, 79 percent of those people are U.S. citizens. Furthermore, KFF reports in a 2008 primer on theuninsured, "70 percent are from families with one or more full-timeworkers and 12 percent are from families with part-time workers;two-thirds are poor or near poor; young adults, ages 19 to 29, comprisea disproportionately large share of the uninsured, mostly because oftheir low incomes; and minorities are much more likely to be uninsuredthan whites." Moore knows many people have opinions aboutsubsidized medical care. But really, he says, we're already paying forit through the back door. HOW HE'D FIX IT: The fundamental issue for Moore is rethinkingwhat he really values. If you look at our economy as a whole, how muchis appropriate to spend on health care? Should it be more than ondefense? Entertainment? In 2007, the country spent 16 percent of the GDP onhealth care, according to the Congressional Budget Office, and Moorethinks that's well worth it. "You have to decide really what is good health careworth," he says. "Because taking good care of people is expensive.There's just no way around it." While we already spend a great deal on health care, our outcomes don't match that of other Western countries. Why? "It's because our system is so inefficient," he says. "The money is not used to actually take care of people." So, to provide coverage for everyone, Moore thinksmoney can be redistributed from current inefficiencies. For instance,having to spend money on coders, or people who just manage all themountains of paper work, raises prices for care. If there were a moreefficient overall system, used by everyone in the medical field, thatmoney could be saved and costs lowered, he says. Also, electronic medical records offer some hope,he thinks. While the technology is in the beginning stages, Dr. Moorethinks there's a lot of room for improvement and innovation. If there'sa universal system, then money is saved when tests aren't repeated. WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL SAY? While Moore says he's no policywonk, and it does seem like the plan changes from day to day, Moore hasthree other things he think must be included in any bill. First, coverage has to be expanded to makeinsurance available for everyone. That will cut down on trips to theemergency department and costs will go down overall. Second, it has to pay physicians well enough so they'll participate and accept the insurance. "If it winds up like Medicaid, where the payments are so low that most doctors just don't take it, it won't be very useful." And finally, it needs to cover the services thatphysicians recommend: ancillary things like occupational therapy thatMoore says are often crucial to recovery but not covered by Medicaid.
Mike Gorman POSITION: Physical therapist, owner, St. Louis Physical Therapy ISSUES: Insurance
As a business owner, Gorman is troubled that hisinsurance rates have gone up 20 to 25 percent every year for the pastfew years. That means his employees' premiums go up, and they also endup paying more out of pocket. He knows that's true for his patients,too. And it's also true for the rest of the country. From 1999 to 2008, the average employercontribution to health insurance premiums went up 119 percent, from$5,791 to $12,680, according to a 2008 report from the Kaiser FamilyFoundation and Health Research and Educational Trust. For employees,that number rose 117 percent. But from the medical provider side, Gorman says, he's not seeing any of that extra insurance money in what they reimburse for. "I don't mind anyone making money," he says."That's fine, but you have to think, without us doing the care, theywouldn't be able to make their money." HOW WOULD HE FIX IT? Really, Gorman isn't sure how he'd fix insurance. It's kind of a mess, he says. But he does have three ideas. First, he thinks there should be an annual cap oninsurance premium increases, possibly no more than 10 percent. Thiscould help more employers afford insurance, Gorman thinks, and lead tofewer uninsured. Second, Gorman thinks health-care providers shouldbe paid based on quality of care they provide, not quantity. He'dmeasure that quality through looking at both the training those peoplehave and the outcomes they get. And finally, he'd like insurance companies to giveproviders a reimbursement increase once every two years. "How else canhealth-care owners keep up with with their business costs?" WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL SAY? Employers will continue providinghealth insurance or contribute funds for them. But there's alsoassistance for small employers, whose payroll isn't more than $250,000.They're exempt from required coverage, though they'd have to pay apenalty. There's also a tax credit proposed for small employers whowant to provide insurance to their employees, according to the bill. The plan also calls for a cap on annualout-of-pocket spending. Many Democrats believe that a publichealth-insurance option will make the insurance market more competitiveand therefore more affordable.
Dr. Will Chapman POSITION: Professor of Surgery, Director, Division of General Surgery, Chief Abdominal Transplant Section, Washington University ISSUES: Affordability, efficiency
Chapman's other issue, like many of those we spoke with, is efficiency, and it could in some ways help with his first issue. "We can definitely gain efficiency, someefficiency, in the way health care is administered and the way ourplans for care are carried out and the way our systems run." There are often duplications, he says, in tests. That duplication happens because physicians often don't have access to records. "So we end up repeating testing and that's costly." HOW WOULD HE FIX IT? With affordability, Chapman thinksincreased efficiency would go a long way. In addition, electronicmedical records and an established system for testing could trim thefat. "That should result in significant cost savings," he says. "This is not a minor problem, it's a major problem." WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL SAY? Again, several points in the billcover both affordability and efficiency, including a cap on annualout-of-pocket spending and increased competition through a publichealth-insurance option. The plan also focuses on prevention and wellness,but savings might not come right away for many of Chapman's patients.For people with liver cancer, he says, it could take 15 to 20 yearsbefore an impact is apparent. {mospagebreak title="Dr. Karen Webb, Dr. Brian Schurgin, Nurse Mardi Manary"}Dr. Karen Webb POSITION: Chief Medical Officer, Saint Louis University Hospital ISSUES: Access, efficiency
"One of the ongoing challenges in health-care delivery isn't just access to care, but patients being able to access the right care at the right place," Webb says. "People come to us and use our emergency room for non-emergency conditions because they either lack a primary care/family physician, or they feel as though they can't wait to be seen because its after office hours or during a weekend. While urgent care centers have helped to alleviate some of that issue, they don't help solve the problem of continuum of care, or building a relationship between a physician and a patient, which has been known to improve patient quality over time." Often, she says, people can't afford health care, and if they can afford it, they can't get it because of pre-existing conditions. Suddenly, problems pile up. "They don't have health-care coverage and they can't afford it," she says. "Then they can't get good preventive care or any care, and they get critically ill, and that's not very cost effective." Her other issue is efficiency. "It's pretty fragmented," Webb says of the health-care industry. There are many, many parties involved, from hospitals to insurance agencies, drug makers, physicians, pharmacists, and all use different systems for pretty much all they do. "It's just all over the place." HOW SHE'D FIX THEM: There are positives and negatives to the ideas out there for offering access, Webb says. "Our health care system isn't really a 'system' at all; it's made up of many fragmented parts, which is one of the problems. The role that Saint Louis University Hospital plays in the community is, as we say, 'critical' because we offer services and have capabilities that a community hospital wouldn't be able to, so our operational costs are higher than most other facilities." For example, if someone went to SLU Hospital for an MRI, the machine used would be the newest, with the latest technology, since future doctors are learning in the process. "Would a single-payer system take that into consideration when paying health-care providers? I'm not sure. The system is too complicated at this point to assume that one solution will work well for everyone." She does have more ideas for efficiency, though. The mandatory use of electronic medical records would help, she thinks. So would the adoption of evidence-based medicine, which the Centre for Evidence Based Medicine at the University of Oxford describes as "the conscientious, explicit and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients." Basically, it combines clinical knowledge with scientific evidence in determining treatment. WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL (HR 3200) SAY? Under discussion now is a public health-insurance option as well as a provision to require insurance companies to guarantee coverage regardless of age, gender or pre-existing conditions. Other approaches that could affect accessibility are expanding Medicaid, improving Medicare and affordability credits. Those affordability credits are hard to define at this point, since details are sketchy, but essentially they'd benefit low-income people who are ineligible for Medicaid by making insurance premiums more affordable, according to the bill summary. As for efficiency, the plan proposes several solutions, including "modernization and improvement of Medicare," and administrative simplification. Webb thinks many of the options for expanding coverage are viable. And with efficiency, she says, quality and efficiency should be rewarded with incentives; and all the parties involved, from drug companies to hospitals to insurance agencies, should be at the table. "They've all got to be part of the solution."
Dr. Brian Schurgin POSITION: regional medical officer, Schumacher Group, practicing emergency medicine physician, SSM system (In the photo below, Dr. Schurgin is wearing scrubs.) ISSUES: Emergency department overcrowding, nursing shortage
Hospitals often function at 110 percent capacity, and several things happen because of that. The emergency department becomes a holding room when there's overcrowding, so people aren't able to get in right away and get the help they may need. Often, the people coming in aren't truly in need of emergency medical care, but they have acute problems. If that person should be in intensive care unit but instead is the E.R, it's even more work for the already overworked doctors and nurses, says Schurgin. Schurgin's second issue might have something to do with the first -- Nursing shortages, specifically of registered nurses, is a national problem. According to a March 2009 report from Reuters, "116,000 registered nurse positions are unfilled at U.S. hospitals and nearly 100,000 jobs go vacant in nursing homes." HOW WOULD HE FIX THEM? For a long time, the assumption has been that people filling up the E.D.s are the uninsured. They're not, Schurgin says. It's usually the elderly, he says. As baby boomers age, more and more are ending up in the hospital, Schurgin says. That takes up beds, and when beds are full, people sit in the E.D. We need more resources, Schurgin thinks, including more hospital beds. He doesn't just advocate for adding more beds, though, but thinking critically about where they're added and using them efficiently. Also, he thinks we need to look at other options when the aging population is sick. Can people get care at home? Should families have more of the burden of caring for the sick? Also, if people get better preventive care, he says, they're usually healthier. Therefore, they stay out of the hospital. With the nursing shortage, Schurgin wants to see more incentives to get people into the profession, from loan forgiveness to better promotion of the career. While nurses are critical for care and recovery, when there aren't enough of them, Schurgin says, the E.D. can be affected. In a hospital he worked at in Chicago, Dr. Schurgin says there were 300 beds, but only 250 were used. That's because there weren't enough nurses and they had to shut a unit down. WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL SAY? Several proposals could reduce E.D. overcrowding. The plan calls for the expansion of community health centers as well as money to strengthen local health programs. The bill also calls for workforce investments, including "expansion of scholarships and loans for individuals in needed professions and shortage areas."
Mardi Manary POSITION: Home health nurse, Lutheran Senior Services ISSUES: Access, education and advocacy
Those issues -- advocacy, education and accessibility -- intertwine, and like many other issues, branch out further from there. "For us, probably the biggest issue is the underutilization of home health care," Manary says. According to a 2008 report from the National Association for Home Care and Hospice, 7.6 million Americans received home health care. Home health care is essential to people, especially the elderly, Manary says, but often doctors and hospitals don't inform patients about their rights to home health care. It's covered by Medicare and Medicaid in most cases if recommended by a doctor, but often, patients aren't told that, she says. Those patients are discharged from the hospital not fully understanding their medication and wound care and very quickly they end up right back in the E.R. Ultimately, if they do end up with home health care, it can cost two to three times as much after all the hospital visits, and that costs taxpayers and the government more, too. "In the long run, we all pay." HOW WOULD SHE FIX THEM? Manary would like to see better discharge at the hospital, which she thinks should begin from the moment of admission, not the day of discharge. Along with that, she'd like to see patients get better education on their rights for home health care and their options. "All the agencies that work with seniors, especially Medicare, need to be on the forefront of education," she says. Next, with advocacy, Manary believes someone at the hospital, nursing home or Medicare should help patients with their decision making, from simply narrowing down all the choices to helping them understand the fine print. "Health care and rights need to be taught," she says. "People don't understand. We think of it as something someone does to us." As a result, she believes that if seniors have better access to home health care, their care will cost less because of fewer trips to the E.R. WHAT DOES THE HOUSE BILL SAY? Under the summary, a few of Manary's concerns are addressed. Part IV, Prevention and Wellness, calls for, among other things, "Expansion of Community Health Centers; prohibition of cost-sharing for preventive services; creation of community-based programs to deliver prevention and wellness; and funds to strengthen state, local, tribal and territorial public health departments and programs." Of the six bulleted sections for reform, "prevention and wellness" is the shortest. The bill also calls for "administrative simplification," which proposes to simplify paperwork for patients, businesses and providers, and that gets at Manary's biggest concern with the reform. "Everyone wants to reform it with more rules," she says. "What we really need is more leeway." For instance, so many codes are associated with Medicare that Lutheran Senior Services has to hire a coder to make sure they're all correct so they can get paid. Her patients are paying attention to talk of reform, too, and they're also concerned. "Most of our clients are afraid because every time something is reformed, their rights and their benefits are cut." Tomorrow: Three more health-care providers Contact Beacon reporter Kristen Hare.
|
Brent Jones | St. Louis Beacon
This Saturday was the debut of a new show by The Improv Shop that will bring out of town improv teams to St. Louis to play for — and with — a local audience. The Road Show brought teams "Everybody Grok" and "Felt" from Chicago.
We talked to Eric Christensen, producer of the Road Show and member of local improv team "Ted Dangerous"; Katie Nunn, member of "Ted Dangerous" and improv coach; and Melanie Penn and Ranjan Khan, members of local teams "Melanj" and "Magic Ratio"; about the St. Louis improv scene and why it's important to welcome teams from other cities to perform here.
Conversations: Noted essayist Gerald Early talks baseball, race and class
St. Louis author Gerald Early talks about the declining numbers of African Americans in the sport. This story is part of a larger look at class in the region, our series Class: The Great Divide
Doug Williams says the proposed consent decree before the U.S. district court here may not be perfect, but it's the best way to move forward to stop the costs of inadquate waste- and storm-water systems.
M.W. Guzy fears his daughters' affection for trash TV might have been genetically inherited, as he finds himself drawn to the anybody-but-Mitt show, playing on a loop on cable "news' channels.
Miguel Dulick recounts a trans-Honduras tour that, again, reminded him of the power and joy of keeping siblings and parents connected.
In this week's Beacon Roundtable, Dick Weiss, Jason Rosenbaum, Jo Mannies, Robert Joiner and Dale Singer sit down to talk about the Missouri primary and redistricting, the controversy around…
General manager Nicole Hollway is back to the Beacon blog and she's trying to piece together what social media is and means to people.
Ben Finegold says recent moves by Lindenwood and Webster universities have positioned the region to be the chess capita of the United States.
@
Register to receive our daily email of new content. If you're already registered, email us at [email protected] with the subject line "subscribe".
The Missouri Foundation for Health will hold a meeting to highlight its funding strategy for 2012. The meeting is scheduled for 9-11 a.m. on February 1 at the Missouri Foundation for Health's 2nd floor training room in the Grand Central building at Union Station in St. Louis.
Meetings are free and designed for health and community action nonprofits, community service clubs, human service providers and community leaders. RSVPs are encouraged: Contact Maranda Witherspoon at 800-655-5560 or [email protected]. More information.