St. Louis Beacon

Thursday
Sep 02nd
           | 
 
Home arrow Issues/Politics arrow Dividing lines: Arizona's immigration law finds supporters, opponents in the heartland
Dividing lines: Arizona's immigration law finds supporters, opponents in the heartland Print E-mail
By Jo Mannies, Beacon Political Reporter   
Posted 9:50 am Mon., 05.31.10

With St. Charles County officials and his district solidly behind him, state Rep. Mark Parkinson says he definitely will resubmit a proposal to the Missouri Legislature next session patterned after Arizona's new illegal immigration law.

"It will be the first bill I file,'' said Parkinson, R-St. Peters.

parkinson100mark.jpgSuch a pledge is in line with Parkinson's focus on immigration ever since he took office in February 2008 after a special election. Parkinson (right) says his emphasis is welcomed in his district, where 92 percent of his survey respondents said "get tough on on illegal immigration."

In fact, in early May, the St. Charles County Council voted 6-1 in support of Arizona's law and urging the Missouri Legislature to enact a similar law.

Agreeing with this stance, for example, is St. Charles resident Scott Rhoades. Illegal immigration "may not be as big a problem in Missouri as it is Arizona, but it is only a matter of time," Rhoades said.

Arizona's law, which requires authorities to ask for documentation of legal residency from people suspected of being illegal, "should have very little impact on the immigrants already here legally," Rhoades said. "I do not feel it infringes on civil liberties one bit. When I lived in Denmark, I had my passport with me at all times."

Inform our coverage

This article contains information gathered with the help of our Public Insight Network.

The St. Louis Beacon, in partnership with KETC/Channel 9, is using this journalism tool to help us solicit knowledge and insight from people who become sources through the Network.

To learn about the Network and how you can become a source, please click here .

He complained locally of dealing "more and more every day'' with people who cannot speak English, "which is an immediate indication they did not immigrate legally."

Parkinson -- a former aide to Sen. Christopher "Kit" Bond, R-Mo. -- emphasizes that his plan for Missouri will differ from Arizona, in part because of Missouri's different constitutional mandates. His initial version, submitted in mid-April -- with just weeks to go in the last legislative session -- did not, for example, impose any requirements for Missouri law enforcement to check the residency status of people stopped for traffic violations.

The legislator does plan to zero in on such matters as Missouri's drivers license. Foreign students in the state with legal visas are rightly able to apply for state drivers licenses, he said. But in Parkinson's view, the licenses should expire on the same day as the visas; now, the students receive the state's standard six-year license.

"If you overstay your student visa, it's just as illegal as someone crossing the (U.S.) border," Parkinson said.

He also acknowledges that Missouri's immigration problems are far less severe than those in Arizona, which borders Mexico and is a favorite route for illegal immigrants and those who smuggle them into the United States.

simcox150chris.jpgLast weekend, one of the conservative leaders of Arizona's illegal immigration fight -- Chris Simcox (right), founder of the Minuteman Civil Defense Corps -- was in town to lay out the particulars of Arizona's troubles, as he viewed them.

Simcox emphasized in an interview that his focus is on border security, and not so much on the United States' immigration policies. That said, Simcox emphasized his belief that the flood of illegal immigrants into the United States is fueled by some businesses' "desire for cheap labor," and illegal drug trafficking.

Yet, overall, according to Politifact, illegal crossings from Mexico are down, measured by the decrease in border apprehensions. According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, as reported by Politifact, on the southern border, apprehensions dropped from 858,638 in 2007 to 705,005 in 2008 and to 540,865 in 2009.

Simcox appeared at a recent forum in south St. Louis County organized by Republican legislative hopeful Chris Brown, whom Simcox has known for years. Simcox said he is "barnstorming the country'' to campaign for like-minded candidates concerned about security along the United States' borders.

Among other things, Simcox contended that illegal immigrants have been deterred by Arizona's law mandating photo identification for voting and receiving social services. He estimated Arizona has saved $1 billion because of lower demand for such state aid since the identification mandates went into effect.

According to Puneet Kollipara reporting in the Hill, local Tea Party leader Gina Loudon was expected to participate in a rally in Tempe, Ariz., this past weekend to support a "Buycott Arizona" campaign to counter tourism and business boycotts of the state. (Last year, Loudon organized a "Buycott Whole Foods" to show support of the store owner's opposition to health-care reform.) 

Area Hispanic Groups paying close attention

In Missouri, some Hispanic civic leaders are concerned about the legislative proposals advanced by Parkinson, among others. Jorge Riopedre, executive director of the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of Metropolitan St. Louis, said, "We're concerned about the business ramifications of these laws and plan to work with the Missouri Legislature as needed."

The Hispanic Leaders Group of Greater St. Louis plans to make immigration the topic of its next meeting, set for June 9 at the Brown Shoe heaquarters in Clayton.

"We will have a panel discussion on what's happening in our region,'' said chairwoman Cileia Miranda-Yuen.

read more from beacon

Sharing such concerns is Francisco Linan, a retired state worker of Hispanic descent who lives in St. Louis County.

"This implies police can stop anyone any time and ask for legal status. I bet they don't stop whites and ask the same questions," Linan said, recounting a recent incident in which a relative was stopped in Kansas and "had to show his Social Security number as proof of his legal status."

"My friends suggested I place my Social Security number on my left arm with a permanent marker -- I did," Linan said. He recalled that he had served in the military in the Vietnam War.

"I don't understand; I went to Vietnam so that this country could ... practice racial profiling?" he added sarcastically. "And what about the Hispanics -- those come back from Iraq? Do they have to show their Social Security number on their arm or just show the prosthesis? There is a long-lasting solution somewhere, instead of a short and quick solution."

Contact Beacon political reporter Jo Mannies.

 

  No Comments.
Discuss this item on the forums. (0 posts)

Editors' Picks

 
uneasystreet300.jpg

A bad economy hits home in different ways. In this Beacon series of community profiles, St. Louis area residents share their experiences on Uneasy Street and the fight for economic security in their home towns.

Granite City | O'Fallon, Mo. | Maplewood

Floods and Kaskaskia

Drew Canning talks with island residents Courtney "Manny" Brown and Dorothy "Dot" Brown, who recall what life used to be like on Kaskaskia Island. To read more about the island and see a larger version of the slideshow, click here .(Photos by Rachel Heidenry | Beacon intern)

Voices

Beacon Roundtable

Beacon Blog

The Lens


@

Register to receive our daily email of new content.  If you're already registered, email us at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it with the subject line "subscribe".

 

Barroom Conversations

The St. Louis Beacon sponsors every-other-weekly conversations on race, related to the publication's year-long special coverage of issues and situations related to race in the St. Louis region. The lightly-moderated discussions begin with a specific topic, but like all good conversations, veer off in different and rewarding directions. The Barroom Conversations are on summer break, and will resume in September. We look forward to seeing regulars and newcomers when the break is over. Everyone is welcome.

facebook2.jpg

Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.

twitterbutton100sq.jpg

Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.

race100.gif

In St. Louis, race affects virtually every important aspect of community life. Yet it’s difficult to talk productively about race. Race, Frankly invites you to look at race with fresh eyes.

The Missouri History Museum, the Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 have partnered to create a yearlong series of events, in-depth articles and video pieces.

Read stories in the series.

rss75.gif

What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.

RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.

For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.