| Tea Party fits into American tradition |
|
|
| By Lana Stein, Special to the Beacon | |
| Posted 5:00 am Mon., 05.24.10 | |
|
Tea Party adherents strongly believe in minimal government, minimal taxation and individual liberty. Although some Tea people were appalled at the behavior of financial institutions that led to the Great Recession, they criticized the role of government in trying to ameliorate the damage. The Tea Party tenets have been widely shared — although not always dominant — throughout the history of our republic. Our form of government was designed to prevent either the tyranny of the few or of the many. Checks and balances and separation of powers correlate with limited government. Federalism also diffuses power. Our nation was born out of rebellion against a colonial power. It did not evolve over the centuries as European democracies have. European beginnings in absolute monarchy permitted political cultures more comfortable with strong governments, and their political systems frequently offered less possibility of fragmentation. Americans railed against tyranny from day one and idealized the frontiersman, acting alone to carve out a home in the wilderness. Later many revered the person who could rise from humble beginnings to become a business tycoon. Although populists and some Progressives fought the power of the trusts more than 100 years ago, they only achieved a limited victory. In Europe, the landed gentry reigned for centuries and considered commercial and industrial occupations to be coarse and not part of the elite. Entrepreneurs there did not occupy quite the same position they have in the United States. What we seem to forget is that people, whether part of government or the private sector, are all motivated to one degree or another by self-interest. In government, the goal of elected officials is re-election while bureaucrats want the programs they administer to continue amid comfort and stability. Those in the private sector want to make a profit. Writing in the 1960s, John Kenneth Galbraith described corporations that wanted to maintain their profit level and market share, not necessarily maximize them. By 1990, that had changed. Mergers, divestitures and the growth of multinationals led to the hypermobility of capital and profit maximization. Stock price, not the quality of a product, was the means of evaluation. Deregulation became a goal of Democrats and Republicans alike. A plant closing bill was adopted that required businesses to provide two months notice of closing to their employees. A number of opponents fought it as an impediment to the free market. Since corporations focus on the pursuit of profit, does that also inculcate a sense of responsibility to community or country? Not necessarily. Political scientists would say that government comes into play to address those issues the market cannot and will not in order to protect the general public and help those with the least. For example, Hooker Chemical and many other firms polluted land and groundwater over the years. Congress created the Environmental Protection Agency to remediate such pollution and prevent its future occurrence. Would companies have acted on their own? Government at any level carries its own sets of problems. Agencies and their staff are self-interested. They may be inefficient or unaccountable or even both. Politicians certainly exhibit self-interest. This is true anywhere. Institutions and their rules affect behavior. The United States has weak political parties. Basically candidates run on their own and raise their own campaign funds. Interest groups and corporations support candidates, hoping they will cast friendly votes if elected. Elected officials can put pressure on agencies to favor certain interests. The United States is exceptional in that it has extended greater rights to corporations than other democracies. In the latter half of the 19th century, U.S. Supreme Court decisions extended the protections of the 14th Amendment to business, giving them the rights of individual citizens. Ironically, that amendment was meant to extend liberty to the newly freed slaves. In 2009, the Supreme Court, on a 5-to-4 vote, applied freedom of speech to corporate political campaign giving. All too often we deal in stereotypes. We see tycoons as hard-working and creative, from Vanderbilt to Gates. They become heroes. Excesses are often overlooked. On the hand, politicians are seen as corrupt and bureaucrats as purveyors of red tape and either lazy or power hungry. These stereotypes play into the periodic movements for limiting government’s size and mission. The recent severe economic turmoil and government’s attempts to preserve the financial system and stimulate growth led to the Tea Party. Government is blamed. It is treading on me. It will be interesting to see who receives blame for the tragic oil spill in the Gulf: BP, Halliburton or government agencies. The private and the public sector each have pluses and minuses. Americans have habitually seen the pluses of one and the minuses of the other. Taxes are anathema but the hidden costs of private enterprise are overlooked.
Lana Stein is a professor emerita of political science at the University of Missouri at St. Louis. To reach her, contact Beacon features and commentary editor Donna Korando.
|
Report finds drop in illigal immigrant population in U.S.: After years of growth, the recession and stricter law enforcement led to a decline of almost two-thirds between 2005 and 2009. | Washington Post
Hostages released at Discovery Channel headquarters in Maryland: The suspect, James Lee, who had issues with the channel's environmental coverage, was shot and killed by police snipers. | Washington Post
As Hurricane Earl approaches, N. Carolina expands evacuations: Earl weakened to a Category 3 hurricane early Wednesday as it whipped across the Caribbean with winds near 125 mph. | Charlotte Observer
Murkowski concedes in Alaska GOP senatorial primary: The incumbent was defeated by Joe Miller, has never held elected office but enjoyed the backing of former Gov. Sarah Palin and the Tea Party Express. | Wall Street Journal
Five seek Missouri casino license: Besides two applications for spots near Chain of Rocks, the Gaming Commission got two bids for casinos in Sugar Creek near Kansas City and one for Cape Girardeau. | STLtoday
Alternative energy group makes offer to buy ex-Chrysler plant in Fenton: The identity of the potential buyer was not released by the St. Louis County Economic Council, which made the offer public. | KWMU
Judge allows KKK suit against Missouri to proceed: The group said denial of permission to use a pavilion at a state historic site in southern Missouri violated free speech. | AP/KMOX
Cardinal broadcasts returning to KMOX next season: The station had aired the team's games for 51 years before the action moved to KTRS five years ago. | STLtoday
Direct peace talks between Israel and Palestinians to resume in Washington: Issues in the long-stalled negotiations include Israeli settlements and the future status of Jerusalem. | CNN
Four Israeli settlers, including a pregnant woman, killed in West Bank attack: It was the deadliest attack on Israelis in more than two years, coming on the eve of peace talks with the Palestinians in Washington. | New York Times
Chilean rescuers begin drilling to reach trapped miners: The government still says it will take three to four months to reach them. | AP
Five more American killed in Afghanistan: The latest roadside bombs and fire from insurgents raised the death toll to 19 service members since Saturday. | AP
U.S. Rep. Maxine Waters offers defense in ethics case: California Democrat is accused of steering bailout money to OneUnited Bank, which had ties to her husband. | FoxNews.com
Hispanic Republicans criticize Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid for questioning Latinos in GOP: Leaders call Reid's remarks condescending and insulting. | Politico
Former U.S Rep. Dan Rostenkowski dies at 82: Chicago Democrat represented northwest side of town from 1959 to 1995, was chairman of Ways and Means Committe from 1981-1994. | Chicago Tribune
Discounts spur unexpected gain in retail sales in August: The numbers are providing a sliver of hope
for the economic recovery, but worries still remain about the critical
holiday season. | AP
New claims for jobless benefits fall slightly, to 472,000: Applications still exceeded the 463,000 average so far this year. | Bloomberg
A year after cash for clunkers, most automakers report drop in sales: Only Chrysler reported an increase, while GM, Ford, Toyota, Nissan and Honda had losses. | Detroit News
Manufacturing sector grew faster in August: Rising exports overseas and demand from businesses for capital equipment and supplies have helped propel production in factories for a year. | AP
Kirkwood High School's Robert Becker is Missouri's teacher of the year: He has been sharing his love of chemistry with students since 1990. | STLtoday
New Jersey governor fires state's education chief: He had made a clerical error that led to the state's coming up short in an effort to win $400 million in federal Race to the Top money. | Newark Star-Ledger
Mizzou football captain suspended indefinitely after allegation of sexual assault: In court documents, a woman in her early 20s alleges Derrick Washington sexually assaulted her in June. | Columbia Missourian
Washington U. breaks with Target over donation to Minnesota gubernatorial candidate who opposes gay rights: The university won't take part anymore in program where the retailer let students shop after hours. | Student Life
Drew Canning talks with island residents Courtney "Manny" Brown and Dorothy "Dot" Brown, who recall what life used to be like on Kaskaskia Island. To read more about the island and see a larger version of the slideshow, click here .(Photos by Rachel Heidenry | Beacon intern)
Planning for a trip to Mongolia, even if you already in Dalian, China, must be undertaken with care -- particularly when Woodson Gannaway plans to spend no more than $550.
Kira Hudson Banks asks whether the rally was meant to "reclaim" civil rights or dismiss them?
Rep. Todd Akin, Republican incumbent in the 2nd district, discusses specific areas, such as nuclear policy, terrorism and the way in Afghanistan, in which he disagrees with the administration's policies .
Arthur Lieber, Democratic candidate in the 2nd district, focuses on how decisions are made and seven principles, such as no will be deployed without equipment that gives them maximum safety .
In this week's Beacon Roundtable, Dick Weiss, Robert Joiner, Dale Singer and Jo Mannies sit down to talk about a setback for stem-cell research, the elected school board of St.…
Read more...Editor Margaret Wolf Freivogel discusses why combat troups in Iraq and a Muslim cultural center in Manhattan are news that matters for a regional news source.
Read more...The film studios have to be fatigued from the ups and downs of another cycle of Summer! Movie! Blockbusters! Certainly, filmgoers have had enough of less-than super heroes.
@
Register to receive our daily email of new content. If you're already registered, email us at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it with the subject line "subscribe".
The St. Louis Beacon sponsors every-other-weekly conversations on race, related to the publication's year-long special coverage of issues and situations related to race in the St. Louis region. The lightly-moderated discussions begin with a specific topic, but like all good conversations, veer off in different and rewarding directions. The Barroom Conversations are on summer break, and will resume in September. We look forward to seeing regulars and newcomers when the break is over. Everyone is welcome.
Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.
Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.
In St. Louis, race affects virtually every important aspect of community life. Yet it’s difficult to talk productively about race. Race, Frankly invites you to look at race with fresh eyes.
The Missouri History Museum, the Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 have partnered to create a yearlong series of events, in-depth articles and video pieces.
What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.
RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.
For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.