| Missouri, Illinois see mostly party-line vote on health care, but Skelton is the exception |
|
|
| By Jo Mannies, Beacon Political Reporter | |
|
Three Democrats voted for the bill, and Missouri's five GOP members of the U.S. House voted against it. The exception to the party-line split was U.S. Rep. Ike Skelton (left), D-Lexington, who voted against the largely Democratic-crafted bill. He was among 39 Democratic defectors, who were off-set slightly by one supportive Republican vote. The final tally: 220-215. (That means every House member cast a vote, a rare occurrence.) UPDATE: One of those "yes" votes came from U.S. Rep. Russ Carnahan, D-St. Louis, who said at a news conference Monday at Lambert Field airport that the bill's passage is evidence that "momentum is gaining'' for congressional and federal action to change the nation's health care system. Greeted by a couple dozen supporters, Carnahan said he understood that the pressure now is on the U.S. Senate, which he said will likely craft a different health care bill -- but he emphasized that he expected the Senate approve a measure, which then will need to be meshed with the House version. Supporters of health care changes need to keep their eye on the broader objective, and not get enmeshed in debates on the particulars, the congressman said. Carnahan asserted that he wasn't afraid of the political fallout over his support of the Democratic-backed bill. "I did not vote on this bill because of an election,'' Carnahan said, adding that he supported it "because it's the right thing to do." The Washington Post posted online an interesting chart that pairs each legislator's vote with the amount of donations they've received from the insurance industry and the percentage of their constituents who don't have insurance. The comparison makes for some interesting reading and bursts some assumptions. In Missouri, for example, the opponents included U.S. Rep. Todd Akin, R-Town and Country, whose district had the state's lowest percentage of uninsured (under 8 percent), and Rep. Jo Ann Emerson, R-Cape Girardeau, whose district had the highest percentage (almost 20 percent). Carnahan had the second-lowest percentage of uninsured residents. The bill's most outspoken opponent, U.S. Rep. Roy Blunt, R-Springfield, had collected the most donations from insurance companies (about $2.5 million), while fellow opponent Blaine Luetkemeyer, R-St. Elizabeth, had collected the least (just under $62,000). --- Skelton said the final version of the bill was much improved, but not enough. He suggested that Congress deal with "one issue at a time'' in improving health care, instead of passing a massive overhaul. In his statement after the vote, the congressman said:
"I am concerned about the impact the legislation could have on rural hospitals and doctors. The proposed reductions to Medicare reimbursement could further squeeze the budgets of rural health-care providers." Carnahan has been a target of conservative opponents for months because of his continued embrace of the general Democratic proposals to change the nation's health-care system, including a public option. Carnahan was the region's first to fire off a post-vote statement. “After years of effort, months of debate and listening to the ideas and concerns of people throughout Missouri, momentum is on the side of the American people and health-insurance reform,” Carnahan said. “Today we are one step closer to enacting health-insurance reform that controls costs, provides choice and competition, and emphasizes wellness, prevention and shared responsibility.” “If health-care reform were easy we would have accomplished a more sensible system when President Truman was in the White House,” said Carnahan. “For our country to dig ourselves out of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression bold and decisive action is needed." (His announced Republican rival, St. Louis lawyer Ed Martin, soon after issued a statement blasting Carnahan's action.) The region's other Democrat, U.S. Rep. William Lacy Clay, also voted for the bill, as did U.S. Rep. Emanuel Cleaver, D-Kansas City.
Akin had issued a statement Friday making clear that he would not change his mind. Among other things, he asserted that the bill amounted to "levying of billions of dollars of taxes on our small businesses, as well as the consequent losses of millions of more jobs brings the proposal for socializing health care from the realm of the irrational to the dangerously delusional." Said Luetkemeyer, in part, in a lengthy statement after the vote: “By forcing this mammoth overhaul on hard-working Americans, Nancy Pelosi and the liberal majority are creating a health-care system that increases taxes on small businesses, reduces benefits and choices for seniors, and piles insurmountable debt upon our children." U.S. Rep. Roy Blunt, R-Springfield and a candidate for the U.S. Senate, also was quick to issue a statement late Saturday condemning the bill's passage: "It’s families and patients who will suffer most under this government takeover of health care. This bill costs more than $1 trillion, increases premium costs, puts a bureaucrat between you and your doctor, and pays for most of it with Medicare cuts and job-killing tax hikes," he said.
Across the river in Illinois, U.S. Rep. John Shimkus, R-Collinsville, also detailed late Saturday why he opposed the bill.
In his floor speech Shimkus asserted, "The goal of this legislation has been clear from the beginning. To pass a public option that will serve as a gateway to single payer, government-controlled health care."
|
| < Newer post | Older post > |
|---|
Senate votes to open health-care debate: The 60-39 tally along party lines moved the issue over a crucial, preliminary hurdle in a formidable display of muscle-flexing by the Democratic majority. | New York Times
Oprah Winfrey plans to end her program in 2011: By the time of its finale, it will have been on national TV for 25 years. | Chicago Tribune
Giuliani will run for Senate, not governor in New York: He wants to fill out the remaining two years of Hillary Clinton's term. | New York Daily News
Judge rules Army Corps of Engineers was liable for large part of damages from Katrina flooding: The landmark ruling awards $719,000 to four plaintiffs from the New Orleans area. | Christian Science Monitor
Plea deal ends Walmart scuffle trial in southeast Missouri: Heather Ellis avoided a felony conviction and pleaded guilty to resisting arrest and peace disturbance. | AP/KMOX
Big Bend bridge over Highway 40 completed ahead of schedule: It closed June 1 as part of the rebuilding of the eastern half of the highway. | KMOX
Senate Ethics Committee rebukes Burris: It said the Illinois senator's entanglements with former Illinois Gov. Rod Blagojevich reflected unfavorably on the Senate. | Chicago Tribune
Judge sends teen murder suspect to psychiatric hospital: Alyssa Bustamante, 17, is charged with killing her 9-year-old neighbor, Elizabeth Olten, in mid-Missouri last month. | Associated Press
Little-known Belgian premier becomes first full-time president of EU: The choice of Herman Van Rompuy signaled the leaders were not eager to have a high-profile personality represent the EU abroad. | Associated Press
Karzai sworn in for second term as Afghan president: He said the Afghan Army should assume full control of the country’s security within five years. | New York Times
UN urges use of free condoms and family planning advice in fight against global warming: Critics say there is no evidence that a slowdown in population growth would ease effects of climate change. | Associated Press
Iran rejects UN-brokered nuclear fuel deal: The decision effectively rejects the latest plan aimed at preventing Tehran from building nuclear weapons. | AP/Houston Chronicle
Hillary Clinton says she won't run for president again: Secretary of state would be near 70 by 2016, the next time President Obama is not expected to run. | Washington Post
Senate committee approves revisions to Patriot Act: Several senators say they would not support final passage unless changes are made. | Associated Press
Democrats defeat GOP efforts to remove Rangel as Ways and Means chairman: An ethics committee's investigation of Rangel's financial and fundraising activities has been under way for about a year. | Associated Press
Congressional leaders find loophole for spending donations: Leadership PACs are less scrutinized than regular donations. Golf, anyone? | ProPublica
Posted 1:42 p.m. Wed., Nov. 18 - David Weinberg interviews Sr. Jackie Tobin and some of the women involved with Let's Start, a "process dedicated to assisting women in transition from prison life to society," as its website says. "It is unique in that it is coordinated by women who themselves have been through the criminal justice system." To see a larger version of the slideshow, click here .
|
@
Register to receive our daily email of new content. If you're already registered, email us at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it with the subject line "subscribe".
Join the folks who have already found the Beacon on Facebook, the social networking site. See the most popular stories of the day, photos, videos and upcoming events. Visit the St. Louis Beacon page on Facebook and become a fan.
Twitter is a "microblogging" service where users can provide short updates about what they are doing. stlbeacon is our official Twitter feed – check it out to find our featured stories and the news that matters.
In St. Louis, race affects virtually every important aspect of community life. Yet it’s difficult to talk productively about race. Race, Frankly invites you to look at race with fresh eyes.
The Missouri History Museum, the Beacon and KETC/Channel 9 have partnered to create a yearlong series of events, in-depth articles and video pieces. This month, the focus is on health care.
What's this icon? It's the standard icon for RSS.
RSS gives you another option for reading the Beacon, in a way that may be more convenient for you. As explained below, you can use our RSS feed to get alerts about new Beacon content. The Beacon's main RSS feed is here.
For more about RSS, read this quick introduction or watch this video: RSS in simple English.