|
What is Nick's List? Here's teacher Nick Otten's description, "I will read books and
watch movies, and then tell you about them. All kinds of books. All kinds of movies. One often leads me to the other.
"For every single work, I’ll quickly post a brief commentary — each week, at least 1
book and 2 movies, usually more. Maybe a paragraph, maybe a page. Sometimes, not often, I
may go crazy and write some kind of extra on a movie or pair
of movies or some genre, actor, or something else, or how one book relates
to another or a movie or you or me or us."
Book 7
“Repent,
Harlequin!” Said the Ticktockman.
Harlan Ellison,
il. by Rick Berry, Underwood Books, Grass Valley, CA, 1997.
A big (8 1/4”
x 13”) illustrated hardcover book on thick slick paper with 43
unnumbered pages and 10-12 eerie, techno-cool illustrations. A grad
student gave me this book to read and said that it was profoundly
personal and meaningful for him. Probably true for many Harlan
Ellison fans, since this is a 30th Anniversary Edition
of a short story. The big symbol is a jelly bean. Even
includes a splashy 2-page spread of all his varied publications,
including my own favorite, the unfilmed screenplay for I,
Robot, about which I have already complained (Blade
Runner. While I was reading Ellison’s
little book, a high school sophomore interrrupted me to ask if he
could borrow it.
Movie 29
In Bruges
(Martin
McDonagh, UK, 2008, 107 m.)
I
don’t always like movies in which everybody
has a thick foreign accent — including in this
case the two main characters, Irish
killers — but that’s no interference in
this story. This is a hitman movie, but it’s
weirdly warm and funny, despite the usual and
sometimes not-so-usual gruesome elements.
The story starts quietly and lulls you with a lot of
silly, rough talk, but then it grabs you and won’t
let go. The night I watched it, the film broke
after 30 minutes, and nobody seemed to care —
we were so softened up by the goofy developments on the
screen that the stoppage nearly seemed like another
wry joke. How often does that happen? With
good comic work by Colin Farrell and Ralph Fiennes,
plus Brendan Gleeson (Mad-Eye Moody in
the Harry Potter movies and
riveting in Into the West (1992).
Movie 28
Forbidden
Quest
(Kim
Tae-woo, S. Korea, 2006, 139 m.)
The
last from the Korean Film Festival. The English title
is terrible. It could have been called “Forbidden”
or maybe “The Nobleman Takes Off His Hat,”
but there is no ‘quest’ except in the most
subtle metaphorical sense. This is a very sexy
movie, without showing any more skin
than a Sports Illustrated swimsuit issue.
Actually less, but it is sometimes
a turn-on. A noble courtier who is also
a great writer gets himself tangled up
in writing erotic novels. He enlists other
highly ranked nobility and eventually
the story has to turn tragic. But in the
meantime, it’s both erotic and hilarious.
The ending is a mess, but oh, man, it’s
not possible to predict some of the silly
postmodern jokes that surface in this
movie. I want my own copy.
Book 6
Gossip
Girl
Cecily von
Ziegesar, Warner Bks, 2002.
Just about the
most fun you can have reading about rich teenagers in New York.
This story starts out like a casebook of what “mean girls”
do to each other, but it eventually gets into so much
light-weight poetic justice that it lets you off the hook, and you
can stop worrying about how American girls are crushing each
other, year after year, in middle school. Except this story is
set in high school. And they are all richer than your average
investment banker. So, no, the story is not about real people, at
all, but then, neither are the Indiana Jones stories.
Actually, the story strikes me as very much like an Indiana Jones
story, but set in a Manhattan demimonde with realistic (read nasty)
dialog between high school kids with too much time, money and
power. What would you expect of people who live on Fifth Avenue
across the street from the Metropolitan Museum?
The name-dropping is pretty funny, too. In this book, a
ridiculously studly high school boy wears thousand-dollar shoes, but
the girls who know him definitely disparage him for it. OK, then,
they so have standards.
For literary types, check out the
clever interpolations of the gossip-girl persona that are sprinkled
in. Is the narrator separate from the narrative voice? Is she
actually the main character, as one e-mailer asks? Duh. If you have
to ask, you can’t even, OK? This book (well, this soap
opera) is about purses and stuff, not heuristics. Or something.
Actually, I hate that word. It’s like a Donald-combover for
whenever you don’t want to deal with actual difficultness.
Perfecto for a cool TV series, yes? So right-now. So better than
than a Sex-in-the City-movie about old women. We’re better than
that.
Movie 27
Crossing
the Line
(Daniel
Gordon, UK, 2007, doc., 94 m.)
A
genuinely strange British documentary about US
deserters in the Korean War, some still there, with
wives and families, and arguing with each other about
who’s lying to whom. Thought-provoking as
something can be when you simply would
never have imagined such a story. Who thinks about the
Korean War these days? — and yet the
autobiography of one of the men was reviewed just one
week later in The New Yorker. Surprises
can come easy with documentaries.
Movie 26
A Flower in Hell
(Sin
Sangok, Korea, 1958, 87 m.)
Supposedly
a Korean classic of early noir but it just
seemed amateur to me. A younger brother tries to save
older brother from a floozy babe, but
obsessive love brings them all down.
Movie 25
The Grace
Lee Project
(Grace
Lee, 2005, doc., 68 m.)
The
first of four in a row, one a day, all from the second
Korean Film Festival at Washington University —
and free. A clever little documentary about all the
Asian women named Grace Lee, which
includes the director, of course, who’s
on a wry search for herself by studying
the other women who have her name.
Movie 24
There Will Be Blood (2x)
(Paul
Thomas Anderson, 2007, 158 m.)
Even
better on second viewing. The score is superb, the
directing and editing are superb. It’s like a
silent movie, like Citizen Kane in color, like
a trip into the suppressed hell of a man who lives
only to compete. His two tentative forays into
(family) love prove to be unsatisfactory,
and serve only to make him less human
and more astonishing. Probably one of
the great screen portrayals ever — by
Daniel Day-Lewis. Utterly ferocious.
Maybe an instant classic, as they say.
Movie 23
The Other
Boleyn Girl
(Justin
Chadwick, UK/US 2008, 115 m.)
Sexual
politics meets family politics — not a pretty
picture. Or a nice family. We may never see the end of
American movies explaining Henry VIII. And oh
sorry, but the carriages weren’t around
in those days, although I know nobody
ever expects much real history out of
Hollywood. Even so, the catty-sister
infighting of Anne and Mary Boleyn seems
to be a construct from the arguable novel. The real
Anne Boleyn was apparently at least as complex as her
more famous daughter, Elizabeth, and far
beyond the get-back-at-my-sister sulking of the movie.
The end result is a kind of serious chick flick that
dabbles in politics.
Movie 22
Vantage Point
(Pete
Travis, 2007-8, 90 m.)
Exciting
as hell. No more realistic than a James Bond movie.
First, they kill the President over and over. Later,
they save him. That satisfies most movie viewers. 24
meets The Day of the Jackal meets.
Movie 21
10,000
B.C.
(Roland
Emmerich, 2008, 109 m.)
Misnamed
by half. They should have called it 5,000 B.C.
Of course, that still leaves big trouble over the
wooly mammoths and saber tooth tigers, all
roaming around near the Nile, I guess,
thousands of years too late. Oh, well.
Lots of fun and some weirder-than-usual
warfare for a change. Gathering all the
tribes and organizing with a translator!
A sort of inverse of The 300. While none
of the heroic savages was oiled-up for
weight-training like the Greeks stopping
the Persians, these elephant hunters still
looked good, with excellent dental work
but hardly any cleanliness. And talk
about obsessing over a woman! Who would
have thought that men back then could be so
gentlemanly, compared to now? What backsliders. No
light porn, here, if that’s what you’re
after. These people actually aren’t very savage.
Movie 20
Flawless
(Michael
Radford, UK, 2007, 108 min.)
A
snappy new heist movie with Michael Caine and Demi
Moore. And she’s not bad! Maybe she’s
trying to clean up her rude-girl image and get
sophisticated. If so, she’s off to a good start.
She’s much more like Grace Kelly than Madonna —
for once. She is beautiful, after all. As
always, Caine is excellent. Set in 1960
London with 1million grey suits and
year-round grey weather.
Movie 19
A Scanner
Darkly
(Richard
Linklater, 2006, animated live. action, 100 m.)
I t
gets cooler with more viewings. When I first saw it on
a big screen, it mostly dazzled and confused me with
the funky super-imposed animation and the jazz
dialog. But it’s more than a temporary
CGI trick, I think. After all, this is a tale
by Philip K. Dick, folks. And it’s a real
caution. This is what a summer movie —
unlike the Will Smith I, Robot movie —
should have felt like, but didn’t. But I’m
probably just prejudiced because of how
they took Asimov’s title and screwed up
that whole story. I think this may be the
third time I’m whining about that movie.
But this movie is cool. And how many titles allude to
St. Paul?
Movie 18
Rocky
Balboa
(Sylvester
Stallone, 2006, 102 m.)
A
self-conscious “last hurrah,” which
includes even that phrase, along with a
literal tour of all the important places in Rocky’s
original movie (54., above), such as the pet shop and
ice rink where he wooed Adrian, plus ghostly images of
Adrian all over his house and car and in
his head. Aside from the litany of “This
Is Your Life” Moments from the first
movie, the story is really an excuse for
The Stallion to show us that he is still
“cut” (at the age of 60, folks!) and still
has his original will of steel, even if
that’s about all that’s left. The most
embarrassing moments come at the end
when old Rocky, written, directed, and
played by old Stallone, humbly and
happily accepts the accolades of an
idol- worshipping crowd in Las Vegas. While
a touch of wit does still surface, mostly
the movie feels like Burt Young coming
close to tears to confess yet again that he
was always bad, while Rocky was good.
While the credits roll, nearly half of the
people of Philadelphia do the notorious
victory dance on the steps overlooking
the city: little girls and old people and
obese people and maybe even one or two
from Pittsburgh, as if to say, Rocky is
not only beloved, he’s real and living in
you and me. Humble? And Rambo will be
coming back to big screens this year.
Movie 17
The Rape of Europa
(Richard
Berge & Bonni Cohen, 2006, documentary, 117 m.)
A
suspense-filled movie about the long and concerted
effort of Nazi Germany to grab Europe’s great art
for themselves. Shows just how crazy Hitler could be,
just how greedy and selfish other Nazis
could be, just how surprisingly close the
Indiana Jones movies come to the weird
levels of cultural attack that the Nazis
were contemplating. For all the people
who think that art doesn’t matter —
think again. We live on the symbols.
That’s why Nicolas Cage can even get
away with kidnapping the president in
National Treasure.
Movie 16
Indiana
Jones and the Last Crusade
(Steven
Spielberg, 1989, 126 m.)
Hot
blonde Nazis are way better than old monocled Nazis.
Plus James Bond as Indie’s cool, cranky Dad!
But, please! A 700-year-old knight who apparently
doesn’t eat or — do NOT think about
what you would do for seven hundred years
without leaving the room. Also, the 4-DVD collection
has an entire three hour disc of good bonus material.
Movie 15
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
(Steven
Spielberg, 1984, 118 m.)
This
one is even weirder than God coming out of an ark. If I
were from India, I think this movie might bug me.
Wait. Do NOT think too much about world
religions, if you want to enjoy this movie.
Movie 14
Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark
(Steven
Spielberg, 1981, 115 m.)
In
the beginning, Indie saved the world from the Nazis
with some spectacular reactions from JHVH. As long as
you remember that Lucas’s original idea was
to replicate the Saturday-morning serials
of his youth, these stories are sheer fun.
Do NOT think too much about realities
or politics during these movies.
Movie 13
Youth
Without Youth
(Francis
Ford Coppola, 2007, 124 m.)
Almost
mystical, definitely personal, with a beautifully shot
and somewhat strange story. The story is far less
weird than many foolish Hollywood fantasies,
but the difference is that Coppola isn’t
trying to make a buck — in fact, he very
deliberately made the movie on his
own, with his own money, for the artistic and
editorial freedom to do as he pleased —
he’s trying to make a philosophical
point. Not the usual for a movie. And I
think his point is quite clear, which may be a
problem. What happens if his audiences dislike his
point or disbelieve it? Will that undo the movie? Such
an interesting risk! Would people read and
enjoy a well-written book, even if they
disagreed with its premise, the argument,
and the conclusion? Will they watch such
a movie? We’ll see.
Book 5
Plan B:
Further Thoughts on Faith
Anne Lamott,
Riverhead Books, NY, 2005.
Another personal
book by Anne Lamott, full of her trademark humor about her
quirky adventures in and around her family. This one is
nominally about her Christianity and faith, but I think it’s
really about middle age and motherhood and the endless oddities,
temporary dangers, strange humors and sudden conflicts. She is
clearly beloved by many appreciative and varied readers, but
something about her always leaves me doubtful and even a
little suspicious. I keep thinking that what is a really cute
story may be no fun at all to experience in her company. Clever
metaphors and droll responses to conflicts can ease some pain
for awhile — sometimes. Maybe she gets some free passes
from readers just for being an openly funny & liberal
Christian in a time of aggressive Christian conservatives.
Movie 12
Two Mules
for Sister Sara
(Don
Siegel, 1970, 116 m.)
More
of a Don Seigel movie than a Clint Eastwood movie,
this charmer has the big guy matched line-for-line by
a saucy pretty young Shirley MacLaine who
considerably humanizes the whole story with
her sophisticated version of the old nun/whore male
fantasy. I suppose the 2nd “mule”
in the title is Hogan, the stubborn cowboy who saves
her.
Move 11
Joe Kidd
(John Sturges,
1972, 88 m.)
From
an Elmore Leonard novel. This is a good movie and fun,
but it’s not up to the level of his The Great
Escape or even Bad Day at Black Rock. Maybe it’s
John Saxon, maybe it’s the weak ending,
but at least it has some fun in it. Clint
Eastwood is a reluctant bounty hunter
and shows a little humor.
Movie 10
High
Plains Drifter
(Clint
Eastwood, 1973, 105 m.)
From
a package of “3 Clint Eastwood Westerns.”
This is retrograde old-style stuff. He rides in,
utterly filthy, a classic stranger, and then “has
to” kill 3 bullies. Then he rapes a loudmouth
woman who needs to be raped, the way the bullies
needed to be killed. Vague and
unsupported bits of mysticism float all
through the movie. While the main
character is named The Stranger, this
is more nasty Shane than cool Camus.
Movie 9
Hearts of Darkness: A Filmmaker’s Apocalypse
(Eleanor Coppola,
1991, documentary, 96 minutes)
Her documentary
of her husband’s movie, Apocalypse Now,
shot while he was making the famous 1979 movie based on Conrad’s Heart of
Darkness, re-set in the Vietnam War.
Originally intended as a 5-minute promo
for Showtime on TV, it was shown
theatrically, won an Emmy and ended up on Gene
Siskel’s Top 10 list for 1991. Only
recently released in DVD, it also
includes a commentary from both Eleanor
and Francis Coppola. Along with Lost in La Mancha,
I think this is an excellent view of the weird good
and bad luck that goes into the task of
movie-making — and she doesn’t even touch
on the astonishing amount of post-production —
over 2 years! — or consider the amazing musical
score. Includes her new documentary of FFC’s
recent 62-minute movie, Youth Without
Youth, after 10 years of no filmmaking.
Movie 8
Diary of a Lost Girl
(G.
W. Pabst, GER, 1929, b&w, silent, 116 m. King
Video DVD, remastered)
This
movie is the second in the famous pair made by Pabst
with Louise Brooks. The first was Pandora’s Box.
This one is not quite as good, but still striking, and
with a more “human” story, evident even in
the two titles. Brooks as “little Thymian,” is callously ruined, discarded, uplifted
and makes her way, all despite her own
family. Aside from one genuinely stupid
comic scene, this story is compelling and
sad. Brooks is riveting on the screen,
though not as much as in Pandora’s Box.
Both movies are way ahead of their time
in depicting real-life sex and sin.
Movie 7
Wild at
Heart
(David
Lynch, 1990, 124 m.)
Breasts
and symbols and hot, hot colors and slow, slow music,
usually guitars, and many, many strange moments that
include Elvis, The Wizard of Oz and
body parts (a David Lynch specialty). I
remember being dumbfounded by this movie when it came
out — how would a viewer fit it into any kind of
normal experience? So I was speechless at the
insistent nastiness. And all in the name
of love. The idea of Diane Ladd playing
the murderous mother to her own daughter, Laura Dern,
in this freaky movie is downright odd. The
idea of the French giving the movie The
Golden Palm at Cannes is also a freaky notion, instead
of, for instance, Goodfellas or Ju Dou
in the same year. Oh, well. Even so, Willem Dafoe was
brilliant as the devilish Bobby Peru.
I slept on it and realized what
bugged me so much about watching the
film again: the casual use of time, as if
it’s a joke. People in this movie don’t
seem to think much about the famous
“ravages of time.” Maybe that’s just
obsolete, changed to nips and tucks.
Sailor can go to jail for a few seconds as
a joke on a card: “5 years, 10 months,
21 days later.” When he comes out, his
loving Lula, no longer a 20-year-old,
actually looks better after raising a boy
alone while Daddy is in jail for armed
robbery and attempted murder. And he’s
cute, too, shy and smiling for Daddy, not
troubled or angry. And Mommy still has
her still perfect classic convertible. No
wear or tear on anybody or anything.
Even the Wicked Witch doesn’t age.
Maybe dark humor means never having to
say that pain is real. You can almost see Quentin
Tarantino taking notes as he watches brains splatter
and the cards announce funny time-shifts and
people make cool pulpy wisecracks. I think
that’s fine in, say, Eraserhead or Suture
or even Pulp Fiction, but have a heart,
Lynch, a real heart. The casual misuse of
human time in a movie is like the casual
misuse of space in a painting — things
get to look wrongly unreal, even if they
are hot and flamboyant.
Book 4
The Story
of Doctor Dolittle
Hugh Lofting,
Dell Books, 1920, 1988.
I picked up this
paperback at the public library because it was for sale for 25
cents. What a remarkable innovation this series must have been for
readers in 1920. And it reads faster than a speeding bullet, too. Not
only a surprising style for a World War I-era writer, but also a
pretty thoughtful rendition of animal attitudes. The
detective-like sniffing of Jip the dog is my favorite part of the
book. Some of the original story was amended to avoid
offensiveness, which the editors of this kiddie edition confess
candidly, and with the express permission of the author’s
family, who claim that he himself would have been the first to
make such changes if he were alive today. By now, many American
kids probably think the story is based on the humor of Eddie Murphy.
The original series includes 12 novels.
Movie 6
Rocky
(John
G. Avildsen, 1976, 120 m.)
The
legendary movie that made a star of Sylvester Stallone
and the mall in Philadelphia. Almost better
than I remember it from the theater.
Curiously, I did not remember how much he
had been watching Marlo Brando movies. The iconic
moments are still strong: Rocky on the steps in his
nasty sweats, and swallowing five raw eggs for
breakfast, or screaming for Stella, excuse me, Adrian,
from the ring, half-blinded and bloodied. He deserved
that Oscar for Best Screenplay, though I
don’t know if we deserved to live with the
franchise that followed. His anti-intellectual
street-philosophical yo-Paulie dialog is now an
interesting contrast to that later boy-wonder script
for Good Will Hunting by Matt Damon
and Ben Affleck.
Book 3
Use
Me
Elissa
Schappell, William Morrow, NY, 2000.
A somewhat
frightening novel of a woman’s painfully intense love of
her nearly perfect father. Electra-like in spots, it may make you
hope that nobody tries to build a movie around this story. Still,
it’s well written and has a forward-leaping structure that
covers a surprising amount of time with sureness and clarity. It’s
also witty and funny in the way that only tough New York girls
consider themselves witty and funny.
Movie 5
Chicken Little
(Mark
Dindal, 2005, animated, 81 m.)
A
solid Walt Disney story. I watched i t on DVD on my
laptop with an 8-year-old who would sporadically
switch it to the dubbed French-language version and
then laugh uproariously. The dialog and
allusions are often very clever and adult,
which doesn’t matter. The visuals are
hilarious. Needless to say, this cartoon
doesn’t give the old version, ending with
Foxy Loxy eating five idiotic fowls.
Book 2
The Arts
of David Levine
David Levine,
Alfred A. Knopf, NY, 1978.A big 10 1/2”
square paperback of two kinds of Levine’s artwork, 50 pages
of watercolors.
Delacroix-style
beach scenes, Coney Island landscapes, and meditative, sometimes
heart- rending portraits and another 150 pages of his
caricatures (boy, oh, boy, did he hate Richard Nixon!). These are
mostly musicians, painters, writers and Vietnam-era presidents. And
again he uses cigars and cigarettes as funny props, plus some funny
Frankensteins and spiders. He often surprises: a cranky
Shakespeare, bloated Frank Sinatra, C. P. Snow as Humpty
Dumpty, and two hilarious portraits of Sigmund Freud and Marlon
Brando. His portrait of Edgar Allan Poe may well be
definitive. I’d still like to see what he would do for Emily
Dickinson. Includes a very technical-sounding intro by Thomas S.
Buechner that can teach us all some art lingo, plus the interesting
fact that the artist credited with inventing the caricature is a
17th century Italian painter named Annibale Carracci -- the very word caricature may come from his last name (although
the Merriam-Webster Collegiate seems to disagree).
Movie 4
Little Big Man
(Arthur
Penn, 1970, 139 m.)
I
remember the shock of seeing this movie in the
theater. The Western had not yet been declared “dead,”
although many shots had recently been fired,
especially including Midnight Cowboy
(1969) just the year before. But half of
the neighborhood taverns in the USA
still had giant murals of “Custer’s Last
Stand” on their walls, and he
was still a martyred hero, all over the
country. Only Civil War historians seemed to know that
he was one of the worst students in his West Point class
and widely criticized as stupid, lucky and reckless in the Civil War. But
soon enough, with many revisionist histories, such as Custer Died for
Your Sins (1969) and Bury My Heart at Wounded
Knee (1970), Americans began to rethink “Indian”
issues very seriously. The US was also smack in the
middle of the Vietnam controversy, and what soon happened was that
the conservatives & hawks (e.g., John
Wayne) became symbolic “cowboys” and the
liberals and doves (e.g., hippies) became the
“opposing” symbolic Indians. All over the country, you
could identify people who were anti-Vietnam
just by seeing their “Indians” dress, including rawhide jackets and
moccasins and even hairbands. This movie was a
part of the “liberal” movement, with
Dustin Hoffman, who’d taken on
Mrs. Robinson in The Graduate and had
played Ratso in Midnight Cowboy only
to lose the Oscar for Best Actor to John
Wayne in True Grit, who was praised for
courageously playing the fat old man he
had become. Still, Midnight Cowboy
won for Best Picture and Director, so the
question of which movie’s “politics”
was “winning” remained a hot issue. Little Big Man had a
tremendous effect, partly because it was
anti-hypocrisy, also sexy, and also very
funny, particularly in “Old Lodge Skins,” played by Chief Dan
George. Americans love underdogs and
this movie made the Washita Massacre
even worse than it apparently had been,
and portrayed Custer as vain and stupid
beyond belief, and maybe insane.
Movie 3
Persepolis
(Marjane
Satrapi, 2007, animated autobiography/documentary, 95
m.)
Fine
story-telling in yet another new kind of story-medium:
a full-length animated autobiography. After just
recently reading a full-length book of graphic-novel-style journalism
about Serbia, I’m ready to re-consider the entire issue of
cartooning. Some very serious work is happening in the graphic
cartoon format. The frightening question
is: Will cartoons replace books? I’ve been
thinking about the cartooning of American movies for some
years. The two issues may be converging. This
movie was an Oscar nominee for feature animation, but it didn’t
have a chance in the year of Ratatouille.
Movie 2
Curse of the Jade Scorpion
(Woody
Allen, 2001, 102 m.)
Embarrassing,
although it is at least occasionally funny. On the
evidence of this effort, at least, Woody Allen ought to
stop making movies with himself in them. And judging
from the wooden performances of Dan Aykroyd and Helen
Hunt, he should maybe stop directing and casting, too.
I never heard of this movie, which I got
from the public library, and I can certainly see why.
He also wastes the lovely Charlize Theron in this one.
Movie 1
The Spiderwick Chronicles
(Mark
Waters, 2008, 107 m.)
Mildly
interesting but not really ever scary. The critters
that I wanted to be cute were ugly, and the ones I
expected to be scary were merely predictable. And
it’s another story about bad dads. They are
everywhere in the movies.
Book 1
[Bulfinch’s
Greek and Roman Mythology] The Age of Fable
Thomas Bulfinch,
Dover Thrift Edition, 1855, 2000
Another great
bargain book from Dover Books. For $3.50, you get 300 pages of
Greek, Roman, Hindu, Buddhist and Scandinavian myths and stories.
Since the book has been called simply “Bulfinch” for
over a century, the publisher did not take a chance, and added the
not-quite-accurate description to the original title. I didn’t
realize that the book was first published in 1855, which makes it
yet another classic work from the all-important decade of 1850-60s,
now called the American Renaissance. What a brilliant idea for a
teaching book, back when nobody had even translated some of the
great myths, much less bothered to compile and sort them. I
first heard of the book from a grad-school teacher who said that
any time he needed a poetic topic for his writing, he just read
Bulfinch. In fact, the prose does sometimes achieve its
own rhythmic style, as here explaining creation according to the
Norse Eddas: “They slew Ymir, and out of his body
formed the earth, of his blood the seas, of his bones the
mountains, of his hair the trees, of his skull the heavens, and of
his brain clouds, charged with hail and snow.” Like Edith
Hamilton’s later Mythology, written for the same
purpose, the book is generally considered as mere reference, but
it’s readable in its own right. A big surprise to me is how
very bad so much of the prized poetry of the 1850s sounds now.
Bulfinch salts in many contemporary allusions to the old
classics, and an enormous number are no fun to read. Once again,
the reader also learns that the Greek gods were all too human, and
that loving anybody can be damned dangerous. Interesting
examples of source-phrases, too, including the original use of
cock-and-bull stories and who were called Magi, and of
course, the meanings of many words, such as panic.
|